[TWR]

If you have any questions regarding the Tip.It War Rankings, then please post them in this topic. Suggestions and new ideas are welcome, too.



If you wish to contact a member of staff directly, then you can PM a clan-moderator/community-leader or come to our Tip.It Clan IRC.

[dfchester]

Yes, On TWR "Blessed" Runehead link shows its not found...?

[Loge_05]

I couldn't access their memberlist or forums. If they're still inactive by the next activity-sweep (one month's time), then they'll be removed.

[dfchester]

You should make a section of only videos, would be a great addition, if its TWR war then write "[TWR] Downfall Defeats Imperial Force Video" or if its normal then the same thing but without [TWR]

[Loge_05]

The problem, then, would be that TWR results would be posted in two forums, which could be confusing.



We did have a forum called the Clan Galerry, but it was removed as it wasn't be used. We would resurrect it if it was clearly needed.

[y_guy_4_life]

Loge_05 said:

The problem, then, would be that TWR results would be posted in two forums, which could be confusing.



We did have a forum called the Clan Galerry, but it was removed as it wasn't be used. We would resurrect it if it was clearly needed.

I agree, I don't think its needed, especially as many clans don't film their twr fights.

[dfchester]

On the TWR table, Downfall has 1148 points which is higher the Lgegendz spot, so Downfall comes #6

[Loge_05]

Corrected.

[y_guy_4_life]

In terms of the basic clan wars options, make it so that the following are mandatory for any TWR war:

[*:3v6ymanb]Pots allowed

[*:3v6ymanb]Prayer allowed

[*:3v6ymanb]Food allowed

[*:3v6ymanb]Binds allowed

In my opinion, if any one of these rules isn't honored, the fight cannot be taken seriously.

[dfchester]

That is true, seriously no food or pray is just out of hand, its like a 5 min war.

[20Rice04]

y_guy_4_life said:

In terms of the basic clan wars options, make it so that the following are mandatory for any TWR war:

[*:2el5t7qk]Pots allowed

[*:2el5t7qk]Prayer allowed

[*:2el5t7qk]Food allowed

[*:2el5t7qk]Binds allowed

In my opinion, if any one of these rules isn't honored, the fight cannot be taken seriously.

That's completely unfair. It's bordering on 'nannying' the fights. Who are you to say what a war 'is' or 'isn't?' you cannot demand clans stick to a set of rules because these rules give bigger clans an unfair advantage over lower level, smaller clans.



The TWR system is meant to be a democratic one, not a dictated one, it's up to clans to come to a conclusion through negotiation in order to reach what they think is a 'fair' set of rules. In the event that things get so out of hand that clans cannot reach a fair and just descision then there are the Tip.It House rules which can be agreed on.



Really I think this is just Df having a dig at Tr because we aren't going to bend over backwards to accomodate your every whim.

[Loge_05]

Alright, alright, enough flame-throwing.



The mandatory rules are to prevent abuses of the system (we always ask for pics/vids as proof, we always ask that clans cannot fight one another more than once within a month to prevent point-farming, etc, etc).



I've only read one or two declarations where there has been an argument over food/pots/prayer, so I don't feel there is any justification to alter the rules.

[y_guy_4_life]

20Rice04 said:

y_guy_4_life said:

In terms of the basic clan wars options, make it so that the following are mandatory for any TWR war:

[*:3oapgn4d]Pots allowed

[*:3oapgn4d]Prayer allowed

[*:3oapgn4d]Food allowed

[*:3oapgn4d]Binds allowed

In my opinion, if any one of these rules isn't honored, the fight cannot be taken seriously.

That's completely unfair. It's bordering on 'nannying' the fights. Who are you to say what a war 'is' or 'isn't?' you cannot demand clans stick to a set of rules because these rules give bigger clans an unfair advantage over lower level, smaller clans.



The TWR system is meant to be a democratic one, not a dictated one, it's up to clans to come to a conclusion through negotiation in order to reach what they think is a 'fair' set of rules. In the event that things get so out of hand that clans cannot reach a fair and just descision then there are the Tip.It House rules which can be agreed on.



Really I think this is just Df having a dig at Tr because we aren't going to bend over backwards to accomodate your every whim.

I'm not DF. I'm an outsider. And all that I know is that every thing, every tactic that makes clan war a clan war is negated by having no prayer or food. What is the point of piling or tanking?

[xjcx]

y_guy_4_life said:

In terms of the basic clan wars options, make it so that the following are mandatory for any TWR war:

[*:2v8moqpr]Pots allowed

[*:2v8moqpr]Prayer allowed

[*:2v8moqpr]Food allowed

[*:2v8moqpr]Binds allowed

In my opinion, if any one of these rules isn't honored, the fight cannot be taken seriously.

I agree, I don't see how any official war cannot have these rules.

[VikingShip]

It somehow feels that TK got less points for TK vs TEH war at Rankings

Was there some points sweep for every clan?

[Loge_05]

VikingShip said:

It somehow feels that TK got less points for TK vs TEH war at Rankings

Was there some points sweep for every clan?

TWR Update - 1/5:

Loge_05 said:

As its the first of the month, an activity-check has been performed (inactive clans were removed) and all TWR clans have had their points reduced by 20%.

[Dfdarkpyro]

xjcx said:

y_guy_4_life said:

In terms of the basic clan wars options, make it so that the following are mandatory for any TWR war:

[*:21kb6na8]Pots allowed

[*:21kb6na8]Prayer allowed

[*:21kb6na8]Food allowed

[*:21kb6na8]Binds allowed

In my opinion, if any one of these rules isn't honored, the fight cannot be taken seriously.

I agree, I don't see how any official war cannot have these rules.

+1. It should be that those rules are mandatory unless BOTH CLAN OFFICIALS AGREE OTHERWISE.

[Scorrtty19]

Maybe add to twr information that if u have problem about a war result that u must report it fast.



I posted a problem about a result 1 day after the result is posted but I was to late.

[y_guy_4_life]

Scorrtty19 said:

Maybe add to twr information that if u have problem about a war result that u must report it fast.



I posted a problem about a result 1 day after the result is posted but I was to late.

Sounds like a good idea. Personally I think 1 day after should have been ok though

[lady_ninane]

Scorrtty19 said:

Maybe add to twr information that if u have problem about a war result that u must report it fast.



I posted a problem about a result 1 day after the result is posted but I was to late.

I don't recall that situation where a moderator would IGNORE evidence of rulebreaking presented after points were awarded. But I'm not saying you're wrong--if you could refresh my memory by showing me where this occured?