Jewish woman claims rape.

[Moogel]

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/israel/7901025/Palestinian-jailed-for-rape-after-claiming-to-be-Jewish.html

 

" A Palestinian man has been convicted of rape after having consensual sex with an Israeli woman who believed he was Jewish because he introduced himself as "Daniel". "

"A court in Jerusalem has made international legal history by jailing Sabbar Kashur, a 30-year-old delivery man from East Jerusalem, for 18 months. "

 

What are your guys' thoughts? I found it embarrassing, it's like the Israelis WANT to anger the rest of the middle-east.

[Sy_Accursed]

That just dumb.

 

Rape is non-consensual sex.

It was consensual sex.

 

If anyone should be some how punished it should be her for being stupid enough to assume someones religion based on a name and then try to get him punished for doing nothing illegal.

[EmEss]

... *laughs*

How stupid.

[Moogel]

That just dumb.

 

Rape is non-consensual sex.

It was consensual sex.

 

If anyone should be some how punished it should be her for being stupid enough to assume someones religion based on a name and then try to get him punished for doing nothing illegal.

 

I agree whole-heartedly. Mind you, though, this also went through the court and he's being jailed for 18 months.

Edit: it was "rape by deception" or some stupid bullcrap.

[OldJoe]

Hm, dumb assumption.

Better to spend time to increase prison sentences, more severe punishment and to catch the real asses.

[obfuscator]

That's ridiculous and downright racist.

 

While "rape by deception" does have legitimate legal grounds (see: man pretended to be twin brother) this is nowhere near that.

[Matok]

What are your guys' thoughts? I found it embarrassing, it's like the Israelis WANT to anger the rest of the middle-east.

Embarrassing? probably.

Stupid racist conviction? sure.

but how does a single idiotic judge decision turns out to be "another Israeli attempt to provoke the middle east"...? common, i'm sure you'll have better opportunities for this type of statements.

 

btw this case is probably going to the supreme court and i can't see how it's not going to reverse this stupid decision.

[Serpent Eye]

Facedesking ensued.

[unkn0wnwarrior]

So the name Daniel automatically makes a person Jewish, then? That is the most ridiculous thing I've seen all week. If this sticks, I have lost all faith in their legal system.

[Verminox]

"I love you"

 

Rape by deception?

[magekillr]

Racist Zionism...what else needs to be said?

 

This undermines the public's trust in the very notion of rape by deception by associating it with frivolous racism like this. Quite the blow to the real rape out there that's vastly underreported, and oftentimes ignored.

[Romy]

I'm furious, to be honest. That judge is as dumb as it gets. :evil:

 

What are your guys' thoughts? I found it embarrassing, it's like the Israelis WANT to anger the rest of the middle-east.

Embarrassing? probably.

Stupid racist conviction? sure.

but how does a single idiotic judge decision turns out to be "another Israeli attempt to provoke the middle east"...? common, i'm sure you'll have better opportunities for this type of statements.

 

Yeah, that judge's decision shouldn't be taken as Israel's decision.

[das]

Dude, i've seen countless it was consensual then it's rape cases in America, let alone Israel. the only reason it made the news was because of the silly racial aspects, this happens white on white, black on black usa often and never leaves local news.

[Range_This11]

Psh. How many rape cases do you see on the news? None, unless they're high profile.

[Napalm]

I hope that guy is freed... The real criminal here is that woman for being such an idiot and assuming a name determines an ideology.

[1_man_army]

What are your guys' thoughts? I found it embarrassing, it's like the Israelis WANT to anger the rest of the middle-east.

Embarrassing? probably.

Stupid racist conviction? sure.

but how does a single idiotic judge decision turns out to be "another Israeli attempt to provoke the middle east"...? common, i'm sure you'll have better opportunities for this type of statements.

 

Completely agreed. It's rather unfair to blame all of Israel for one stupid judge, I think anyone who looked at this in any rational way would think that. It's just a stupid judge, stupid case and stupid conviction.

[The_Gabe]

Even I found this in poor taste.

[Pinkbullet3]

Even I found this is poor taste.

lol

[Giordano]

This is why you don't have sex. Its pointless and gives you nothing but trouble. Abinistence ftw.

[The Dark Lord]

Racist Zionism...what else needs to be said?

 

Zionism also upholds fascist Capitalist doctrine because Zionist Jews want to create large corporations and monopolies across globe. They steal Palestinian children in the dead of night for slavery in factories.

 

Капиталисты зла.

 

Communism is the only hope to unite human race and end racial hatred.

[Zierro]

This is why you don't have sex. Its pointless and gives you nothing but trouble. Abinistence ftw.

 

Stop trying to mask the fact that you can't get none! :shame:

 

On topic: The word "rape" is thrown around an awful lot nowadays. If he lied and told her he was a millionaire, then she had sex with him because of that, would that be considered rape? Like someone said earlier, it's a real slap in the face to people who actually were raped.

[fakeitormakeit2]

Hahahahaha

Israel... It is in consistency with you other actions. And one asks how does one judge pertain to the whole of Israel. Weeeell, you see that judge is a judicial representative and decision maker, appointed by Israel, they're policy is an extension of Israel's policy.

[assassin_696]

Amazing. Surely there's an appeals court in Israel that "Daniel" can have this case referred to where some more sensible judges will overturn this stupid, prejudiced woman's take on the law?

 

The judge's summing up statement is staggering in its high-mindedness and presumption:

 

Although conceding that the sex was consensual, district court judge Tzvi Segal concluded that the law had a duty to protect women from "smooth-tongued criminals who can deceive innocent victims at an unbearable price"

"If she hadn't thought the accused was a Jewish bachelor interested in a serious romantic relationship, she would not have co-operated," Mrs Segal said as she delivered her verdict.

 

Anyone who meets a guy and minutes later is riding him in the nearest empty space they can find doesn't have wedding floral arrangements at the front of their mind.

[Romy]

Hahahahaha

Israel... It is in consistency with you other actions. And one asks how does one judge pertain to the whole of Israel. Weeeell, you see that judge is a judicial representative and decision maker, appointed by Israel, they're policy is an extension of Israel's policy.

 

http://public.findlaw.com/civil-rights/race-discrimination/race-discrimination-history.html

 

Would you say any of these are an extension of USA's policy?

[fakeitormakeit2]

Hahahahaha

Israel... It is in consistency with you other actions. And one asks how does one judge pertain to the whole of Israel. Weeeell, you see that judge is a judicial representative and decision maker, appointed by Israel, they're policy is an extension of Israel's policy.

 

http://public.findlaw.com/civil-rights/race-discrimination/race-discrimination-history.html

 

Would you say any of these are an extension of USA's policy?

In context of the time the case occurred, yes. I'm sure there were many kangaroo courts post Civil War just to convict blacks regardless of being actually guilty, and that reflected a general Southern mindset towards blacks at the time. Legislation may be written, but the judges are those who interpret the application. They put the finishing touches on legal policy.