Jump to content

Welcome to Rune Tips, the first ever RuneScape help site. We aim to offer skill guides, quest guides, maps, calculators, informative databases, tips, and much more to help you get the most from the Massive Online Adventure Game, RuneScape, by Jagex Ltd © 2009.

Report Ad

Welcome to Forum.Tip.It
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. If you already have an account, login here - otherwise create an account for free today!
Photo

Tip.It Times - 8th August 2010


  • Please log in to reply
105 replies to this topic

#61
jettrider
[ Display Name History ]

jettrider

    Dark Wizard Robe

  • Members
  • 818 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Grand Exchange
  • Joined:25 October 2007
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Jettrider
  • Clan:DGS


How on earth do you make 2m/hr with skilling? :unsure:


Farming herbs, picking trees, making (unf) pots, Puro-Puro if you have a decent amount of luck, making summoning scrolls (doesn't directly involve combat).


So I'm reading:

1. Farming, which is high hourly profit if you only consider time spent farming but bad daily profit.
2. Luck from a minigame.
3. Buying stuff from the GE and creating junk/items that will crash when people realize the price difference.

How about a SUSTAINABLE skilling method? I'm sure Puro Puro is good average cash, but it involves luck. Monsters like Frost Dragons involve no luck whatsoever. And when you add luck to monsterhunting, the hourly profits get crazy.

2496 Completionist


#62
Jonanananas
[ Display Name History ]

Jonanananas

    Varrock Guard

  • Members
  • 1,308 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Germany
  • Joined:14 November 2009
  • RuneScape Status:Retired
  • RSN:Jonanananas
  • Clan:World60pengs
Farming is all nice and fine, but it's limited. From what I know about it(I don't have the level for it), Impling Hunting at Puro Puro is often too crowded, and Mos'le Harmless has been nerfed.

Regarding unfinished potions, is herb cleaning included here? I'd think so? Well anyway, if not, then there's no xp for it...but if yes, then you have to consider that this is a LOT of clicking, which will quickly become tedious and even may lead to problems with your hand if you do it a lot.

Oh, and are these Methods really at 2m/h? Or is that a 'slight' exaggeration here?

I'd think Farming maybe without unusable time, but the other both(for puro-puro:uncrowded world but no average luck)?

#63
Aneron
[ Display Name History ]

Aneron

    Ghost Cloak

  • Members
  • 1,782 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Joined:11 December 2005
  • RuneScape Status:Retired
  • RSN:Aneron
  • Clan:DGS



How on earth do you make 2m/hr with skilling? :unsure:


Farming herbs, picking trees, making (unf) pots, Puro-Puro if you have a decent amount of luck, making summoning scrolls (doesn't directly involve combat).


So I'm reading:

1. Farming, which is high hourly profit if you only consider time spent farming but bad daily profit.
2. Luck from a minigame.
3. Buying stuff from the GE and creating junk/items that will crash when people realize the price difference.

How about a SUSTAINABLE skilling method? I'm sure Puro Puro is good average cash, but it involves luck. Monsters like Frost Dragons involve no luck whatsoever. And when you add luck to monsterhunting, the hourly profits get crazy.


unf pots aren't junk lol, people buy them because they are too lazy to mix their own pots. it makes just as much sense for unf pots to cost more than their ingredients as it does for air orbs to cost more than glass orbs + 3 cosmic runes. I know for a fact that at least some of the time they are unbuyable

I also don't see how you're complaining about relying on luck in puro-puro, as literally almost every way of making money through combat is luck-based as well. dragons are really the only exception, and the only dragon that is substantially better than RCing is frost dragons. And sure they're better, but doesn't it make sense that they do? To make millions per hour there you need, in addition to 85 dungeoneering, 99 attack and strength, 89 herblore, 95 prayer, and 96 summoning. DOESN'T THAT BLOODY WELL DESERVE A LOT OF MONEY? That is 49.2M xp that must be gained in order to make these profits, much of it very expensive.

I guess it could be argued that skilling does not have the opportunity to use its various components together in such a synergistic manner, but oh well. RS has more players interested in combat than skilling, and I don't see why Jagex shouldn't cater to the larger group more than the smaller group. The difference is there, but it isn't so large as to be truly unfair.

#64
MstrMonopoly
[ Display Name History ]

MstrMonopoly

    Varrock Guard

  • Members
  • 1,369 posts
  • Gender:Not Telling
  • Joined:1 April 2009
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:MstrMonopoly
By the way, the best way of making money in the game is merchanting, which doesn't really involve combat at all.


I piety the fool.

#65
gompo
[ Display Name History ]

gompo

    Chicken Feather

  • Members
  • 23 posts
  • Gender:Not Telling
  • Joined:8 January 2010
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Gompo
  • Clan:AESOP
the first article...

ok, i have played RS for a while now, when i started it was very important to me that i become self sufficient. i wanted to gather my own resources so i wouldnt need to buy what i wanted or needed. at first, this seemed to work, but the longer i played, the more difficult it became.

some examples:

if i wanted to use the best hatchet (the adze may be equal but untradeable, wonder why the dragon hatchet isnt?) in the game to WC, i either had to kill something and hope i would get the random drop or buy one. nothing i do in the rest of the game gives me this tool, it is worthless as a weapon. no matter my smithing, crafting, construction or any skill, i can not make one or obtain it with what i am doing while skilling. i wonder how much crying and wailing there would be if skillers got the best weapon in the game while farming high level crops. of course the same can be said about the best pick in RS as well.

i get better seeds from killing some of the monsters in RS than i can get from thieving from the so-called "master farmer". heck, i cant even get the occasional seed while harvesting my plots (has RS seeds been genetically altered to make me buy from the seed manufacturer??)

i can make, what seems to be, medium level armor, while having the best level smithing in the game. sure rune items sell and alch for decent cash, but hunting rune rocks is a real life pain in the rear. i can get the same armor and weapons in drops from monsters. but i can not make dragon, god, barrows, and many other items that were not in the game when smithing rune was king.

i can fletch, mage, craft, construct, mine, cook, thieve, rc, smith, farm, squeeze by, make potions, chop, burn, and fish everything that is possible for me to do in RS, yet i can not make a dark bow (some may require a boost, but i can do the limit of all listed, except effigies).

with very few exceptions, combat will net you almost everything you should need skills for. why skill?

with a bit of imagination, jagex could make some of the items available to skillers, in the least, allow skillers to get a very rare clue, or in the least a way to be able to make the items that we should be able to make (even if they make skills like dung, and make us get to level 120)

with effigies and assist, is there anything that combat players cant do?

wouldnt effigies be great if you could get them skilling.

the second article...

well, i may be an abnormal RS player but combat is boring to me. sometimes i like doing it, but the same can be said about all my skills. i have always jumped from one skill to another, and never busted my rear and solely done one skill to 99.

with the addition of shattered heart, i need to do 9 of the 15 skills that i thought i would never need to do again. in order to get the bonuses. i get to make fires for no benefit (at this time), cook (strange part is, i cant even cook what i want to), fish (again, i cant even fish what i want to), run agility (OMG!!! i never, ever wanted to do this one again!), thieve (thank the deities the seeds are at least slightly better than what i used to get), smith, etc.

so yes, i have said "i hate doing this", it is irritating that i need to do skills that i thought i was finished training (note: i would still do some of these skills, just not "train" them).

i work toward the skill level max, to me that is more important than how many toys or cash i have. that is the goal of this "game" to me. i have played many games in my life and still play them even if i HATE TO LOSE! so i hate to train ranging? does that mean i shouldnt play the game to its (skill level max) end? i hate to sacrifice a pawn, but isnt it worth it to win?

not every action in every game is always enjoyable, but as i said, for me, the point in this game is to be the best i can be. if i am doing combat, i hate to die, when i am chipping gems and they shatter, i hate it. but i keep after it to try to be the best i can.

some skills to some players at some time will always get a "i hate this" response whether in game or sitting at your computer ready to pull your hair out.

i do admit, when i see someone "power" training say "this is boring" and i respond "take a break" but then they say "but i want to do "x" . those players do irritate me. but we all want that next level to open up new possibilities for us, so i probably should not throw stones.

so i do play RS for the "reward" and it is not always the same reward or the reward others are looking for. i sometimes just stand around in a bank and talk with friends, i have danced with friends for literally hours, i change my bank around and other things that are rewarding to me. if i saw an interesting event and i hadent planed other things, i might possibly join in even if the reward was not "monetary" or "items" or "experience". but as i am sure many people do not live in RS and they have a RL, so sometimes, i want to play the "game" in a manner that helps me achieve my goals (to be the best i can be) and the times i do not mind just being in RS may not be the times the "events" happen..

thanks,
gompo

No matter where you go, there you are.



Posted Image


#66
Obtaurian
[ Display Name History ]

Obtaurian

    Dragon Slayer

  • Members
  • 5,853 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:California.
  • Joined:27 April 2007
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Obtaurian
  • Clan:Dungeonsweepers (DGS)

unf pots aren't junk lol, people buy them because they are too lazy to mix their own pots. it makes just as much sense for unf pots to cost more than their ingredients as it does for air orbs to cost more than glass orbs + 3 cosmic runes. I know for a fact that at least some of the time they are unbuyable

I also don't see how you're complaining about relying on luck in puro-puro, as literally almost every way of making money through combat is luck-based as well. dragons are really the only exception, and the only dragon that is substantially better than RCing is frost dragons. And sure they're better, but doesn't it make sense that they do? To make millions per hour there you need, in addition to 85 dungeoneering, 99 attack and strength, 89 herblore, 95 prayer, and 96 summoning. DOESN'T THAT BLOODY WELL DESERVE A LOT OF MONEY? That is 49.2M xp that must be gained in order to make these profits, much of it very expensive.

I guess it could be argued that skilling does not have the opportunity to use its various components together in such a synergistic manner, but oh well. RS has more players interested in combat than skilling, and I don't see why Jagex shouldn't cater to the larger group more than the smaller group. The difference is there, but it isn't so large as to be truly unfair.


Well said. Impling hunting and rune mining are two of the best ways to make money from skilling, but they both involve a little luck and competition (though nowhere near that of MHing).

Regarding unfinished potions, is herb cleaning included here? I'd think so? Well anyway, if not, then there's no xp for it...but if yes, then you have to consider that this is a LOT of clicking, which will quickly become tedious and even may lead to problems with your hand if you do it a lot.


In Runescape, you often sacrifice experience for money. This applies to MHing especially, so that's a moot point.

Posted Image

To put it bluntly, [bleep] off.


#67
Troacctid
[ Display Name History ]

Troacctid

    Ice Giant Melter

  • Members
  • 4,419 posts
  • Gender:Female
  • Location:California
  • Joined:27 February 2008
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Troacctid
  • Clan:The Farming Guild

How about a SUSTAINABLE skilling method? I'm sure Puro Puro is good average cash, but it involves luck. Monsters like Frost Dragons involve no luck whatsoever. And when you add luck to monsterhunting, the hourly profits get crazy.

Even without any kingly/dragon implings Puro Puro is like 500-800kish gp/hr at least.

#68
jettrider
[ Display Name History ]

jettrider

    Dark Wizard Robe

  • Members
  • 818 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Grand Exchange
  • Joined:25 October 2007
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Jettrider
  • Clan:DGS

unf pots aren't junk lol, people buy them because they are too lazy to mix their own pots. it makes just as much sense for unf pots to cost more than their ingredients as it does for air orbs to cost more than glass orbs + 3 cosmic runes. I know for a fact that at least some of the time they are unbuyable


Hence why I said items that will crash when people realize the price difference. Unfinished potions are forever limited in profit because they are kept in check by the fact that anyone can buy them and at some point it becomes equally worth it to make unf pots yourself instead of buying them. Same with summoning scrolls. Drops from monsters are held in the same balance but they have requirements to obtain; also, since the items sought for profit are generally the best available for their respective slot, prices are guaranteed to remain higher than less useful items. The reason why monsterhunting is such high gp/hour is that most people kill monsters inefficiently and someone with the best gear and stats can rip through monsters faster, while the vast majority of the supply comes from players clogging up worlds with slower kills/hr rates.


I also don't see how you're complaining about relying on luck in puro-puro, as literally almost every way of making money through combat is luck-based as well. dragons are really the only exception, and the only dragon that is substantially better than RCing is frost dragons. And sure they're better, but doesn't it make sense that they do? To make millions per hour there you need, in addition to 85 dungeoneering, 99 attack and strength, 89 herblore, 95 prayer, and 96 summoning. DOESN'T THAT BLOODY WELL DESERVE A LOT OF MONEY? That is 49.2M xp that must be gained in order to make these profits, much of it very expensive.


With the exception of dungeoneering, those levels are commonplace now. Being high leveled with good gear/stats no longer distinguishes players from each other. Also, Kingly Implings have a pretty high hunter requirement (91) that requires 80+ hours of Hunter to achieve (finding kingly/dragon implings is going to make or break your hourly profit). Look it up on the highscores - there are similar amounts of people with 95 prayer as there are people with 91 hunter (herblore is a little behind because at that rank the level is 86). Hard to believe, sure, but prayer are herblore are standard skills now. 80+ hours gives you about 82-83 dungeoneering, depending on your method for the early levels, close enough to sprint to 85. The only requirement that doesn't match up is summoning and the combat skills, but since everyone trains combat and many methods do not rely on Winter Storage, this is not a huge issue. There are a myriad of profitable monsters to kill where the high hourly profits come from 100% or common drops; if you really want a full list, I'll respond with one.

Combat is already the standard. We clearly need methods that require more than level 91 in a skill if profits are going to go anywhere with skilling.

When you start talking about monsters that involve luck, they go like this:
DKs (96 summoning gives most of the hourly profit; drops that are 1/30-1/50 boost this rate on a steady basis).
TDs (with the best methods, averages one set of claws per 7 hours; most players kill them much more slowly, so one set of claws every 10-15 hours for 88 summoners)
GWD (the average hilt takes more than a dozen hours of killing, with secondary drops more common)
Corp (you miss most of the sigils you see, which are rare in the first place)

When you talk about hours per kingly impling or hours per dragon claws, you start talking about profits that are not set. However, skilling is supposed to provide the steady cashflow, and we still have no cashmaking methods that require over level 91 in a skill (whereas high skills like 96/99 summoning, 89/96 herblore, 95 prayer play a huge role in combat's hourly profits). To solve the combat/skilling issue, Jagex is going to have to create higher level content for skilling. Things like the Living Rock Caverns are great for helping people max out but they do nothing for the people looking for ways to make money off this work.

2496 Completionist


#69
Troacctid
[ Display Name History ]

Troacctid

    Ice Giant Melter

  • Members
  • 4,419 posts
  • Gender:Female
  • Location:California
  • Joined:27 February 2008
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Troacctid
  • Clan:The Farming Guild

With the exception of dungeoneering, those levels are commonplace now. Being high leveled with good gear/stats no longer distinguishes players from each other. Also, Kingly Implings have a pretty high hunter requirement (91) that requires 80+ hours of Hunter to achieve (finding kingly/dragon implings is going to make or break your hourly profit). Look it up on the highscores - there are similar amounts of people with 95 prayer as there are people with 91 hunter (herblore is a little behind because at that rank the level is 86). Hard to believe, sure, but prayer are herblore are standard skills now. 80+ hours gives you about 82-83 dungeoneering, depending on your method for the early levels, close enough to sprint to 85. The only requirement that doesn't match up is summoning and the combat skills, but since everyone trains combat and many methods do not rely on Winter Storage, this is not a huge issue. There are a myriad of profitable monsters to kill where the high hourly profits come from 100% or common drops; if you really want a full list, I'll respond with one.

Yeah, combat also requires 80+ hours of training to get to that level. And you only need 88 hunter, not 91.

When you talk about hours per kingly impling or hours per dragon claws, you start talking about profits that are not set. However, skilling is supposed to provide the steady cashflow, and we still have no cashmaking methods that require over level 91 in a skill (whereas high skills like 96/99 summoning, 89/96 herblore, 95 prayer play a huge role in combat's hourly profits).

Even without any kingly/dragon implings Puro Puro is like 500-800kish gp/hr at least.



#70
Wingless
[ Display Name History ]

Wingless

    Hobgoblin Killer

  • Members
  • 1,707 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:pl_upward
  • Joined:14 November 2007
  • RuneScape Status:Retired
  • RSN:Nephilim



How on earth do you make 2m/hr with skilling? :unsure:


Farming herbs, picking trees, making (unf) pots, Puro-Puro if you have a decent amount of luck, making summoning scrolls (doesn't directly involve combat).


So I'm reading:

1. Farming, which is high hourly profit if you only consider time spent farming but bad daily profit.
2. Luck from a minigame.
3. Buying stuff from the GE and creating junk/items that will crash when people realize the price difference.

How about a SUSTAINABLE skilling method? I'm sure Puro Puro is good average cash, but it involves luck. Monsters like Frost Dragons involve no luck whatsoever. And when you add luck to monsterhunting, the hourly profits get crazy.


I thhink someone has missed out RuneCrafting.

At around 91+ RCing you earn approximately 20K each Nature Altar run which, at a good speed, is about 1 minute (judging from best time, being around 41s or so). 20K x 60 = 1.2M
So whereas 2M is near enough impossible p/h w/ Skilling, with RCing you can get pretty close. Sure, 91 RC is high but it's worth it.

Posted Image


#71
Sesquialtera
[ Display Name History ]

Sesquialtera

    Rat Meat

  • Members
  • 34 posts
  • Gender:Female
  • Joined:7 August 2010
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Sesquialtera
  • Clan:Spirits of Arianwyn

the first article...

ok, i have played RS for a while now, when i started it was very important to me that i become self sufficient. i wanted to gather my own resources so i wouldnt need to buy what i wanted or needed. at first, this seemed to work, but the longer i played, the more difficult it became.

some examples:

if i wanted to use the best hatchet (the adze may be equal but untradeable, wonder why the dragon hatchet isnt?) in the game to WC, i either had to kill something and hope i would get the random drop or buy one. nothing i do in the rest of the game gives me this tool, it is worthless as a weapon. no matter my smithing, crafting, construction or any skill, i can not make one or obtain it with what i am doing while skilling. i wonder how much crying and wailing there would be if skillers got the best weapon in the game while farming high level crops. of course the same can be said about the best pick in RS as well.

i get better seeds from killing some of the monsters in RS than i can get from thieving from the so-called "master farmer". heck, i cant even get the occasional seed while harvesting my plots (has RS seeds been genetically altered to make me buy from the seed manufacturer??)

i can make, what seems to be, medium level armor, while having the best level smithing in the game. sure rune items sell and alch for decent cash, but hunting rune rocks is a real life pain in the rear. i can get the same armor and weapons in drops from monsters. but i can not make dragon, god, barrows, and many other items that were not in the game when smithing rune was king.

i can fletch, mage, craft, construct, mine, cook, thieve, rc, smith, farm, squeeze by, make potions, chop, burn, and fish everything that is possible for me to do in RS, yet i can not make a dark bow (some may require a boost, but i can do the limit of all listed, except effigies).

with very few exceptions, combat will net you almost everything you should need skills for. why skill?

with a bit of imagination, jagex could make some of the items available to skillers, in the least, allow skillers to get a very rare clue, or in the least a way to be able to make the items that we should be able to make (even if they make skills like dung, and make us get to level 120)

with effigies and assist, is there anything that combat players cant do?

wouldnt effigies be great if you could get them skilling.

the second article...

well, i may be an abnormal RS player but combat is boring to me. sometimes i like doing it, but the same can be said about all my skills. i have always jumped from one skill to another, and never busted my rear and solely done one skill to 99.

with the addition of shattered heart, i need to do 9 of the 15 skills that i thought i would never need to do again. in order to get the bonuses. i get to make fires for no benefit (at this time), cook (strange part is, i cant even cook what i want to), fish (again, i cant even fish what i want to), run agility (OMG!!! i never, ever wanted to do this one again!), thieve (thank the deities the seeds are at least slightly better than what i used to get), smith, etc.

so yes, i have said "i hate doing this", it is irritating that i need to do skills that i thought i was finished training (note: i would still do some of these skills, just not "train" them).

i work toward the skill level max, to me that is more important than how many toys or cash i have. that is the goal of this "game" to me. i have played many games in my life and still play them even if i HATE TO LOSE! so i hate to train ranging? does that mean i shouldnt play the game to its (skill level max) end? i hate to sacrifice a pawn, but isnt it worth it to win?

not every action in every game is always enjoyable, but as i said, for me, the point in this game is to be the best i can be. if i am doing combat, i hate to die, when i am chipping gems and they shatter, i hate it. but i keep after it to try to be the best i can.

some skills to some players at some time will always get a "i hate this" response whether in game or sitting at your computer ready to pull your hair out.

i do admit, when i see someone "power" training say "this is boring" and i respond "take a break" but then they say "but i want to do "x" . those players do irritate me. but we all want that next level to open up new possibilities for us, so i probably should not throw stones.

so i do play RS for the "reward" and it is not always the same reward or the reward others are looking for. i sometimes just stand around in a bank and talk with friends, i have danced with friends for literally hours, i change my bank around and other things that are rewarding to me. if i saw an interesting event and i hadent planed other things, i might possibly join in even if the reward was not "monetary" or "items" or "experience". but as i am sure many people do not live in RS and they have a RL, so sometimes, i want to play the "game" in a manner that helps me achieve my goals (to be the best i can be) and the times i do not mind just being in RS may not be the times the "events" happen..

thanks,
gompo


Sorry about re-posting this whole thing (I don't know how to hide it, lol)...but very well said, gompo. :mrgreen:


#72
stonewall337
[ Display Name History ]

stonewall337

    Ice Giant Melter

  • Members
  • 3,681 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Joined:17 September 2007
  • RuneScape Status:Retired
  • RSN:Stonewall337
  • Clan:<Killing Time> of Dawnbringer






No one plays this game and doesn't have fun.



I can guarantee you that they do.

Introduce me to them sometime, that's all I'm going to say on this topic.


Go to rogues den and ask who is having fun and enjoying themselves. I would bet that not all of them will be. The same if you asked people the same question to people who are firemaking or fletching.

They may not be having fun at that moment. But why don't you ask them if they have ever had fun playing this game. People do things not because it is fun at that instant, but because it will be fun later, or was fun before. Yes, I hate firemaking, it is not fun. But EE was well worth it, and thus, I did have fun, just not lighting logs.

No one starts playing runescape and says "This is the most boring thing ever, I think I will come back here and play for the next 3 and 1/2 years, just so I can gripe and whine while I get 99 cooking, fletching, woodcutting, and firemaking."

A girl in my clan got 99 cooking at rogues den a bit ago. She didn't have fun doing it, I can guarantee that. I was a primary conversation partner with her via cc while she was roasting sharks. But now she has this cool new cape, and the ability to make a host of new outfits with it. (I guess somebody has to like that color purple, even if I don't) That is how she had fun.

Just because someone is not having fun at that time does not mean they do not have fun playing Runescape.

No one plays Runescape and does not have fun.


OT:

For the first article, it makes sense, but I do not see an easy fix. I do not see a way that Jagex can make skilling earn anything on par with MHing without causing huge inflation (while mining, you uncover a ancient artifact, swap it in at edge bank to Mandrith for money)

Since most people find that having large amounts of money is far preferable to being permanently broke, quite a few people train skills in fast manners in order to finish quickly and get to making lots of money.



How can you say that no one players runescape and does not have fun when in your statement you say you did not have fun while firemaking? That is the point of the whole article I think. People are willing to play a game where they are not having fun to have something small such as a cape at the end. Is it really worth it to spend hours of boredom for a pixelated item such as that, when you can be having much more fun going to a TET event for example?

Ye gods, is it that hard? He said people don't play RuneScape if they NEVER have fun. Is training slayer 100% fun? NO! Is slaying fun? YES.

Stonewall337.png

Drops

#73
MstrMonopoly
[ Display Name History ]

MstrMonopoly

    Varrock Guard

  • Members
  • 1,369 posts
  • Gender:Not Telling
  • Joined:1 April 2009
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:MstrMonopoly

I r playing runescape in way jamflax did not intend game 2 be played i play game solo.


If you insist on playing the game in a [developmentally delayed]ed way, then you deserve to be saddled with the penalties :thumbdown:


I piety the fool.

#74
jettrider
[ Display Name History ]

jettrider

    Dark Wizard Robe

  • Members
  • 818 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Grand Exchange
  • Joined:25 October 2007
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Jettrider
  • Clan:DGS

With the exception of dungeoneering, those levels are commonplace now. Being high leveled with good gear/stats no longer distinguishes players from each other. Also, Kingly Implings have a pretty high hunter requirement (91) that requires 80+ hours of Hunter to achieve (finding kingly/dragon implings is going to make or break your hourly profit). Look it up on the highscores - there are similar amounts of people with 95 prayer as there are people with 91 hunter (herblore is a little behind because at that rank the level is 86). Hard to believe, sure, but prayer are herblore are standard skills now. 80+ hours gives you about 82-83 dungeoneering, depending on your method for the early levels, close enough to sprint to 85. The only requirement that doesn't match up is summoning and the combat skills, but since everyone trains combat and many methods do not rely on Winter Storage, this is not a huge issue. There are a myriad of profitable monsters to kill where the high hourly profits come from 100% or common drops; if you really want a full list, I'll respond with one.

Yeah, combat also requires 80+ hours of training to get to that level. And you only need 88 hunter, not 91.


If you are considering potions/boosts, 86 herblore becomes as good as 89. And is counting hours for combat really necessary? Over 100k people have 99 attack and even more have strength.

When you talk about hours per kingly impling or hours per dragon claws, you start talking about profits that are not set. However, skilling is supposed to provide the steady cashflow, and we still have no cashmaking methods that require over level 91 in a skill (whereas high skills like 96/99 summoning, 89/96 herblore, 95 prayer play a huge role in combat's hourly profits).

Even without any kingly/dragon implings Puro Puro is like 500-800kish gp/hr at least.


Yes, I read that. By "make or break" I meant getting that 500-800k (which doesn't cut it anymore) or a couple million or more.





How on earth do you make 2m/hr with skilling? :unsure:


Farming herbs, picking trees, making (unf) pots, Puro-Puro if you have a decent amount of luck, making summoning scrolls (doesn't directly involve combat).


So I'm reading:

1. Farming, which is high hourly profit if you only consider time spent farming but bad daily profit.
2. Luck from a minigame.
3. Buying stuff from the GE and creating junk/items that will crash when people realize the price difference.

How about a SUSTAINABLE skilling method? I'm sure Puro Puro is good average cash, but it involves luck. Monsters like Frost Dragons involve no luck whatsoever. And when you add luck to monsterhunting, the hourly profits get crazy.


I thhink someone has missed out RuneCrafting.

At around 91+ RCing you earn approximately 20K each Nature Altar run which, at a good speed, is about 1 minute (judging from best time, being around 41s or so). 20K x 60 = 1.2M
So whereas 2M is near enough impossible p/h w/ Skilling, with RCing you can get pretty close. Sure, 91 RC is high but it's worth it.


Bit more like 15k per run, but even so, 1.2m is 60% of 2m. Since when is 60% "pretty close?" Actually, more profit is made crafting deaths through the abyss with chances at double runes (which make it nearly impossible to calculate exact hourly profits, but more than nats) in the 90s. I'd guess 1.3-1.4m perhaps. Still, this stuff is just breaking the 1m mark or creeping up towards 1.5m and is not equaling the 2m number thrown out there or even getting close to the 2.5m average at frost dragons or the 5m some people claim to get at TDs.

It's clear that 91 is no longer high enough to be a level requirement exclusive enough to grant massive profits if Jagex wants to realign the game towards a skilling/monsterhunting balance as far as cash in concerned. I think they'll opt to do all the skilling changes through D&Ds and minigames though instead of frequent new content. The latest skill-related updates in reverse chronological order were:

-Ancient Effigies
-Fish Flingers
-Bonus XP Weekend (if you would count that)
-Shattered Hearts
-New Implings
-Familiarization
-Chance at 2x death, law, blood
-Agility benefits to Hunter
-High level herblore potions
-Ivy
-Living Rock Caverns

Of those 11 updates, 5 were D&Ds or event weekends, 1 was combat-oriented, 2 boosted skill-related moneymaking, and 3 increased the exp rates or ease of training. Take what you want from those numbers but I've stated my conclusion above.

2496 Completionist


#75
PereGrin
[ Display Name History ]

PereGrin

    Skeleton Shield

  • Members
  • 1,092 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Joined:19 January 2009
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Pere Grin



How on earth do you make 2m/hr with skilling? :unsure:


Farming herbs, picking trees, making (unf) pots, Puro-Puro if you have a decent amount of luck, making summoning scrolls (doesn't directly involve combat).


So I'm reading:

1. Farming, which is high hourly profit if you only consider time spent farming but bad daily profit.
2. Luck from a minigame.
3. Buying stuff from the GE and creating junk/items that will crash when people realize the price difference.

How about a SUSTAINABLE skilling method? I'm sure Puro Puro is good average cash, but it involves luck. Monsters like Frost Dragons involve no luck whatsoever. And when you add luck to monsterhunting, the hourly profits get crazy.

the price difference between unf pots and herbs has been there forever. There are at least 20 guides on youtube about "making uber fast cash!! omgz!!"

Lots of people know about it, but it is a mind numbing process, and therefore, very few people actually do it. Plenty of people buy unf pots, so they can finish the huge amount of potions they need to make to lvl up that much faster.

#76
Mini_Spawn
[ Display Name History ]

Mini_Spawn

    Goblin Armour

  • Members
  • 127 posts
  • Joined:3 August 2009
in response to the article regarding skillers I'd like to point out the living rock cavern- faster xp and more money for a higher (albeit combat based) risk. But I don't get how jagex can increase the risk involved in skilling without making mh-ing obsolete. If I don't risk dying doing it (skilling) and make the same amount that's the activity I'll do. This in turn would result in the masses turning to this new method of skilling because it has a lower risk than mh-ing which would inflate this new product to the point of it being obsolete and the masses would then return to mh-ing.

I don't see how jagex can further increase risk permanently- 10% chance at losing experience? our axes used to break and that didn't deter anybody.

I suppose I should clarify that this argument is based on high risk = high reward
Posted Image

#77
vox1st
[ Display Name History ]

vox1st

    Unicorn Horn

  • Members
  • 181 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Pacific standard time
  • Joined:4 August 2008
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:vox1st

How on earth do you make 2m/hr with skilling? :unsure:


Yeah, I am all ears.
XBL: Zwolf wolf
When Runescape Gives you lemons, Alch them!
Posted Image
Sorry Brand, I was a man in the first place, sorry to disappoint you. :\

#78
MstrMonopoly
[ Display Name History ]

MstrMonopoly

    Varrock Guard

  • Members
  • 1,369 posts
  • Gender:Not Telling
  • Joined:1 April 2009
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:MstrMonopoly


How on earth do you make 2m/hr with skilling? :unsure:


Yeah, I am all ears.


Already stated. 2m/hr isn't fantastic, but it's certainly very decent. In fact, 1-90 or so Hunter only takes 80 hours, whereas it takes, say, 1000 (conservatively) to become an elite TD slayer. Let's say it takes you 45 minutes for each quest (about correct if you average out MEP II and Doric's Quest), so that's about 180 hours right there. Extreme potions, requiring 88 herblore (I won't even count overloads, and I'll assume stew) costs at least 90M or so from Level One. Assuming an income rate of 3m/hr, this takes 30 hours to make the money for the potions and about 40-50 hours to make the potions, assuming optimal experience rates. That's 230 hours already. Then we go ahead and get maxed melee (200 hours from 1-99 Attack, Strength, Defence each), and maxed range (cannon/chinning, so only about 60 hours). 230 + 600 + 60 = 890. But wait, there's more. You also want full void, which is about 100 points an hour, so another 11 hours spent getting that full set. In addition, you need your own set of Dragon Claws, so 11 hours on that (assuming income again, of 3m/hr). We're now up to 912 hours. Then, you need to get a unicorn. (not steel titan) I'll assume that you maxed melee on wfiends or something so you have all the crimson charms you need. It's still another 40 or so hours at least to make all the pouches. 952 hours, plus then the roughly 184M you need to make for turmoil, which is another 90-100 hours. That's 1050 hours. If you play extremely well and do the quests very fast, 1000 hours might be within reason.


I piety the fool.

#79
gompo
[ Display Name History ]

gompo

    Chicken Feather

  • Members
  • 23 posts
  • Gender:Not Telling
  • Joined:8 January 2010
  • RuneScape Status:P2P
  • RSN:Gompo
  • Clan:AESOP

*snip*

" high risk = high reward"

*snip*


i would agree with this statement...... before gravestones.

combat, for the most part, aint what it used to be, but the rewards are much better.

thanks,
gompo

No matter where you go, there you are.



Posted Image


#80
stonewall337
[ Display Name History ]

stonewall337

    Ice Giant Melter

  • Members
  • 3,681 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Joined:17 September 2007
  • RuneScape Status:Retired
  • RSN:Stonewall337
  • Clan:<Killing Time> of Dawnbringer
I'm still confused why people who don't need the 500m shields, etc etc, need to make better GP? Sure, you make half the gp/hr I do, but You also don't have a 700m gear tab, 100+ hours in just untradeable gear (imbued rings, PC, BA, etc) and over a BILLION in training stats, etc.

Heck, f2p'ers make bad GP/hr, but outside of rares, what do they have that costs more then like 4m for sara armor?

Stonewall337.png

Drops




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users