There seems to be 2 reasons why people don't want Dusty and runes in the top 15, and I'l try to explain why I disagree with both of them
1 They have been doing an above EHP method for a long period of time
Yes, but is that really enough to kick them out of the top 15? They are not the only one who has been doing over EHP methods. Lynx Titan used his alt as a runner for a period of time and he has also used many other above EHP methods, should we kick him out of the top 15 because of that? I would say No. Simple because he is one of the 15th closest people to 200m all assuming macro efficiency to the average player in the HLC.
2 People don't think they will get 200m all
I feel like Malt Lickeys is sorta in the same boat, I don't think he will ever get 200m all because he only play like he is going for 200m slayer (doing GWD for money). Do I think this is a good enough reason to kick him out of the top 15? No, because i don't want the top 15 to be based on assumptions on how the players are going to play in the future, and because of the same reason above.
I guess another problem with Runes and Dusty compared to Lickeys is that they has done alot of a above EHP method for a long time, but I still don't think that is enough. This is of course very opinion based, and I'm completely fine with people disagreeing with me. That's why i wanted to poll it to see what the majority want's with the top 15 updates, but I guess it's understandable that people didn't click the link. I am the most famous runescape phisher after all.