Oh, I was permanently muted about 2 years ago (of course I played RS Classic before then also). Funny thing; I didn't get any appeals, I didn't get to see the evidence against me until I messaged JaGeX about it: It was a log with me being silly saying random things with my friends while mining. Apparently I was item AND password scamming by doing so (especially with the added lolololols and roflmaos in there; that must be a new trick to scamming of all kinds). Honestly, what the hell is the point of playing the game if you cannot interact with other players? It removes the whole "Massively Multiplayer" aspect of the online game. You might as well just permanently ban someone... muting is like multiplayer gaming torture, except with a different name. I support. To add onto what I've already said; how does JaGeX determine how many blackmarks an offense is worth? There are different ways to get into trouble. ALSO, for the record, not everyone who is muted has done something horribly wrong to get into that position. Many, many people are muted unfairly (such as mod abuse or just plain ignorance, and you can't say I'm wrong about the ignorance -- I mean, look at the update we're getting Jan. 2nd). Still, you probably aren't going to get anywhere with this unless you were to post it on the official RS forums.