I'm contesting one quite far down the list that said that Scythe's spawned only in the Wilderness. This is untrue, I got my Scythe (first drop of the day! 7:30 AM! Woo!) in Draynor Village while I was killing Dark Wizards, just north-west of where Niles, Miles and Giles used to stand.
Anything you can dig up on the Digsite (exception to the Zaros Symbol, of course.) Someone mentioned belt buckles (I only read to page 6) but you also get Old Teeth, Broken Pots and the usual broken arrows, staves, boots and buttons.
Meh, I had one year of members, that was cool... Became a legend, completed Plague City storyline... But, now its all gone, a passing memory on a swift wind... Sorry, I felt like being poetic.