I'd say they've far too alike for it to just be a coincidence. That's one difference that you mentioned and there are at least five similarities that I could mention right off the bat. I really don't think Jagex could 'coincidentally' come up with an item that's very similar to one that's in a very popular movie. Obviously there was some inspiration :P Lol I don't understand how that movie was so flipping popular. I finished reading the book(for the tenth time :roll: ) ANd went to watch the movie, halfway into it I turned it off. The movie is absolutely horrible. They Dumbldore appear to be a homosexual, The opening scene is horribly different from the book........ O oops :oops: Yes there is alot of similaritys