Hello OK, dungeon fishing I think is best even after nerfing, never done it myself I hate those dungeon. Now the question about the next three, Barbarian with urns, Rocktails with Urns and Trout n Salmon with Urns. Having tried all these three here is how I find them. Barbarian with urns I do not find the fastest, I did this with an invent full of Decorative Urns except for two empty spaces, then I did catch two drop two for an hour and managed roughly 44k, and that is with Urns :( Love to know how people get the 60 to 70k that I read of. Rocktails with Urns XP is all over the place, anywhere between 44 to 55k plus an hour, no constant rate but the good GP. Now for Trout n Salmon at Shilo with Decorative Urns, using an Ibis I can get a a constant 48 to over 50k an hour.