Well I let my kitten grow into a cat so I could catch 100 rats for Varrock Diary 2. I have completed this, and now I need to get another cat to choose the color for the Diary. I have the Ring of Charos(a), which means I have done the required quests. I am equipping it, my cat is fully grown, I even have the 100 gp to buy another cat, but she says I have to finish taking care of the kitten I already have, even though it is a cat (meaning this "kitten" that I apprently have is already grown into a cat)... Am I missing something? Any ideas?

Never mind I had to shoo away my cat to get another one, even though I am supposed to be able to get one... -.-

Well I let my kitten grow into a cat so I could catch 100 rats for Varrock Diary 2. I have completed this, and now I need to get another cat to choose the color for the Diary. I have the Ring of Charos(a), which means I have done the required quests. I am equipping it, my cat is fully grown, I even have the 100 gp to buy another cat, but she says I have to finish taking care of the kitten I already have, even though it is a cat (meaning this "kitten" that I apprently have is already grown into a cat)... Am I missing something? Any ideas?

 

You can only get another cat once your original is "overgrown." I know, I had this problem too. Shooing it away works, though, although I would have traded it for the 100 death runes in West Ardougne.