On Oct 12th I received a message from jagex saying I am banned for 1 day and received a black mark for the following 60 sec chat Muskee: Trading pots for herbs -Muskee-trading high level pots for herbs- muskee-Muskee:trading high level pots for herbs-muskee Muskee:No tar- Other person:u sd high lvl pots- Muskee:i id them for u?- other person:um..ok- gave the following herbs-total of 10 herbs-ranaar 3 irit 1 kwuarm 1 lantadyme 1 marentill 2 tar 1 and cadantine1 ther person says:I want my herbs bak- Muskee:i dont do mar-other person-not pots- Muskee:I trade pots for herbs i said- other person:no i want my herbs-I report u muskee- Muskee:pots back then. T The rest of conversation didnt show up but I gave him his herbs back and he kept the pots. I was trying swap my potions for herbs, a practice i do daily, and i was traded by a player, i gave him back potions as stated and he then wanted the herbs back and i gave him both herbs and the potions and he reported me. i got banned 1 day for "item scamming". I feel this affects the whole community of rs, I gave him his herbs back ided and he kept the pots-so he got free ided herbs and pots at my expense. I got the ban and black mark. Im wondering if there is anyone out there that agrees with me as to how unfair my black mark is? I have decided that I will not help others unless I know them well as it is a risk of lossing my char. Its too bad the game has gone this way.