koaala
-
Posts
47 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Events
Blogs
Posts posted by koaala
-
-
But if you wanna say someone is wrong you have to validate why they are wrong; else it doesn't achieve anything. The OP is no better off as no-one has actually shown their answer is more correct.
If you are going to contradict someone's advice you gotta give the why/how to validate that you are in fact the one who has it correct.
They are wrong because they are ignorant or stupid, that's the whole point. H&A isn't a metagame discussion board and shouldn't considered to be. Everyone can't always explain everything, but there is alot of knowledge that is accepted in groups and considered not to be worth explaining. If someone asks what ring style to use with a hex, you say sniper, and report anyone who says desperado.
No-one is asking for a meta-game discussion.
You just have 3 outcomes for wrong advice:
1) post your advice without any extra comment; op is no better off they dunno which advice is right.
2) flame the person who has it wrong and post your advice; probably start a flame war and op still has no way to see which advice is right.
3) post your advice and v. briefly note that the other advice is wrong because...; oh look the op has their advice as one set has justified why it is right and unless reasonably challenged (which I suppose culd drift into meta-game discussion slightly) its done and dusted.
In most cases it doesn't even take a lot to justify since you will known where the fact is that proves your advice and can easily drop a url or quote or the logic behind it.
And Obtaurian I have never tried to argue my personal experience as proof; I have posted it yes and note it as such and its only become argued when others insist THEIR personal experience some how proves mine wrong.
Or 4) Post your advice, say someone elses advice is incorrect, report their advice. Mods delete the incorrect advice. Everybody is happy. :thumbsup:
-
But if you wanna say someone is wrong you have to validate why they are wrong; else it doesn't achieve anything. The OP is no better off as no-one has actually shown their answer is more correct.
If you are going to contradict someone's advice you gotta give the why/how to validate that you are in fact the one who has it correct.
They are wrong because they are ignorant or stupid, that's the whole point. H&A isn't a metagame discussion board and shouldn't considered to be. Everyone can't always explain everything, but there is alot of knowledge that is accepted in groups and considered not to be worth explaining. If someone asks what ring style to use with a hex, you say sniper, and report anyone who says desperado.
-
As I've said time and time again prove me wrong and I'm happy to take it. Call me and a liar and flame me without proving a thing and I'm not gonna take it.
Also memory and personal experience does cover a lot of advice well because I read everything I can about RS, question advice I see I'm interested in and unsure about and I have a good memory for such things. Plus if you look at threads where I've discredited other people I do so without flaming and provided links to the relevant info that proves me correct.
But all this doesn't alter the fact most of my advice is perfectly fine, most of the threads that turn into flame wars I'm not actually conclusively proven wrong or even proven right. And the few I am proven wrong never needed a flame war and I apologise on for my mistake.
H&A, as said earlier, isn't really about explaining knowledge of the game, rather giving advice. Explanations would belong to the metagame(which we don't yet have) forum. Blatant stupidity and ignorance go under the trolling/flaming rule, so it's completely ok to say you are wrong, give the right answer and report your post for flaming trolling. That's why i say giving bad advice is what really matters, not the good advice.
-
I am adamant when I know what I'm saying is true based on my personal experience.
All I ask is if you think/know I'm wrong prove it, flamewars start because people expect me to just say oh my memories and personal experience must be wrong because one person said they are without giving anything more substantial than their experience/memory. One persons personal experience or memory is no more valid as proof as mine, so if you wanna say I'm wrong give proof. If you do that I happily take my mistake or experience of a bug that isn't correct.
That or people flame me as lying or w/e when I clearly say "as far as I know... but im not sure" or similar and I bite back cause its my nature; I don;t take people flaming me for no good reason.
But I also report my own flame wars to make sure they get tidied up and force myself to leave them.
People just remember the bad threads, no-one recalls the many threads I give perfectly correct advice in. Or the threads I give fine advice in then get flamed for no reason based on people carrying grudges. Or the many website corrections I perfectly correctly give. Or the posts were I am proven wrong and do apologise.
But yeah dires bit bout trolling ppl hu dont explain isn't good. I wasn't agreeing to that part; hence I didn't mention it.
I really loved you defending the artisan workshow up until you realised(after a long process of yur stubbornness) that you'd need to make 15m an hour for it to be any good. Personal experience and memories really aren't enough to give good advice, you need to educate yourself and keep your eyes open, if you aren't sure about something, DON'T, for the love of god, post your advice. It's evident that everyone can't know everything, and people being ignorant is where alot of the flamewars start. You don't need to be perfect, just perfect about the advice you give. Anyone can give good advice, the goal is to give the least amout of bad advice.
-
I can't say i am glad that Grimy bunyip is leaving, nor do i care much. But i am VERY glad that people that are assosciated with Grimy bunyip are leaving.One of them is the biggest [wagon] on this forum.
Just leave the forum already :thumbup:
:thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup:
Thing is, you don't even need to ask people to leave over there. Just get 20 or so people to say they don't like that person, the admins get to kick 'em out. Handy right?
It's a foolproof system designed to stop people getting banned for no reason.
Why don't they leave? Contrary to belief of some people here, they aren't as replacable and the administration holds strong intrest in keeping them here, so it comes as no surprise that it was 100% efficiency crowd who was asked to help with guides on the main page, and 0% from any of the anti efficiency people.... Being opposed to efficiency doesn't hold any talents or make you special, while efficiency does.
Sy, i've seen you time and again be very adamant about things you've been wrong about, and each and every time it turns into a flamewar. If you do not have the knowledge it's obvious that you'd be advised not to post- people on the H&A aren't nannies and it's obvious that there will be tentions when someone is being ignorant. As to what dire said, saying he trolls people who don't explain give advice(which isn't nessesary) is just saying he breaks the rules. People on the H&A aren't your slaves, and if anything, they should earn the respect of what a teacher gets.
-
You guys gotta get off the followers band wagon here. Every time someone with a little reputation gets banned or does something inappropriate and gets punished you all start defending the person because you think they care.
You gotta stop drooling over these e-famous no namers, like Justin Bieber, and deal with your own lives. I don't wanna see another loser become famous over night because he made a youtube video over a rs update, and turn that person into a sage.
I think most of the accusations and negative attitude on this thread comes out of spite and shows how low part of the commuity can go. Most have absolutely no idea about what people got banned for, and if even TIF administrators say multiple bans were for bogus reasons, it really shows why the efficiency crowd can't exist peacefully on these forums- moderation turns a blind eye to vengeful insults on this thread, but contributing users get banned for basically nothing. There are people who got banned and had absolutely no relation to what happent later, and those users still get ridiculed, and judging by the blank letters sent out, even high TIF administration has no idea about who did what, so it's highly offensive to accuse anyone at this point.
This is getting dull now; from all I've skimmed over it basically seems:
The efficiency lot have got the knickers in a twist because moderators are telling them they are not allowed to be rude, derogatory and flamey towards people who post perfectly valid advice even if it is not the most efficient advice.
The solution I see is:
Get off yer high-horse let the mods do their jobs and accept the fact not everybody is an efficiency person. Yes you can disagree with advice or post a more efficient alternative but that does not require being rude, derogatory or flamey. All you gotta do is give you're advice and tag on the end the above advice is out-dated or incorrect because x,y,z or so and so advice works but this method is more efficient.
This situation had nothing to do with what you said in your post. Great job on missing the point entirely and yet again showing a large portion of users in negative light. You are very good at it. The efficiency community has already made extensive proposals on how to improve the H&A and Peter of TIF administration has said they are working on impementing them, so you are in no way the first who is trying to improve something.
As for your attitude in H&A, if you are COMPLETELY in the wrong, you will still argue for your point until the other person proves everything about your advice wrong, and after they've done that, you walk away without saying sorring for giving terrible advice or anything. If anything, your way of argueing until the horse is dead and never admitting you can be wrong is very much unhelpful for H&A.
It didn't help me much either when so called "Efficient players" viewed my Help and Advice topics only to spread the word, just for their own sake of "We know best". They need to learn to respect other players way of playing the game, if they want respect back.
And in most cases where "Efficient players" posted on my Help and Advice topics, very often they started replying with a short comment, following it with a elaborated post when i accused them of trolling.
Should make a rule for Help and Advice topics: If your gonna reply to a topic, make sure you elaborate/argument for or write a decent detailed post. They lacked that alot of the times. So i am glad they are leaving. They are unecessary, not important and easy replaceable.
I don't see what explaining things and giving advice has in common. As far as i can tell, if you are in the posession of the knowledge, simply stating what would be best is more than enough. Discussions about why would be part of the metagame forums. There is never a need to be an ass if someone just follows trough and gives blank advice, as that is ultimately the goal. I think it's more than fair to say that you are an extremely offensive person when asking for advice and are very slow to pick up new things. I will definitely wish TIF good luck on replacing the crowd, as i know it won't be easy(particularly if DGS leaves or even stops catering for TIF).
-
From my point of view, the "said accused" have not shown any justice for themselves by resorting to spamming and terrorizing threads over the past 24 hours. In my seat, it looks like this only solidifies the point that the "said accused" have no self control and resort to immature behavior when they don't get their way.
That is a bogus accusation. I'd really love to see the proof that people that were wrongfully banned were behind any of this further rulebreaking. That part of your post is very much insensible flame and shows you are as much in the wrong here as anyone. Weather you want to believe it or not, the backlash came from the community, so it really shows that there are people who genuinly care. I doubt being friendly towards everything is what alot of the people here look for and really wouldn't make tif in any way special.
-
TBH, it is far from surprising that the people banned were the same ones that stopped posting on the Times thread when rules on that became a little stricter...
So the forum rules in general got stricter, any surprise that they stop posting there now too?
@Golvellius: your posts on this thread are probably spot on...
I'm not sad to see some of these people leave, and I also doubt that (and I quote) "half of the Tip.it forum" will leave over this...
Speaking from past experiences: cya around when you cooled your heels...
Only on TIF would users get banned for not being unpopular among moderators. If such a community is fine by any of you, enjoy it while it lasts(as i'm hopeful there will be changes around here in the coming days).
As for all that transpired, if even administrators(yes, multiple) say the bans that caused all this backlash were unwarranted, there isn't much to argue about who or what was wrong in the situation. To clarify this, I don't think ancient had anything to do with the spamming and i went to sleep hours before any of this even happent and woke up not knowing anything about it, thus it's fair to say that atleast the community is active and insightful enough to tell right from wrong and fight for those who no longer can themselves. If mods want to ban someone, go ahead, but please, do it on just ground, otherwise it's not good for any of us.
-
I still can't understand people disregarding virtus. It's the 2nd best melee armor out there(for most things, basically because of healing and no negative melee) and clearly the best corp gear around(hand and shoulders above anything else). If anything, torva is the most useless set(as there is not much use for the higher defense).
How in the world is it better Corp gear than Pernix? Even though it does have 26% melee absorb for a full set, it has under 150 melee defense and 76 magic defense. Regardless of healing and absorb, you'll get hit with pretty much everything an awful lot in Virtus.
Pernix has major negative melee attack, which is a huge problem with zammy spear. Melee def and absorption is useless at corp solo. Virtus has decent mage absorption, decent mage def(both compared to karils) and gives a load more lp with brews(which is what you want).
-
Hey,
i'm looking for dungeoneering CC for a noob with low combat and low dungeoneering.
Friendly people are also a plus.
Levels:
Combat: 108
Dungeoneering: 60
username: lox
try dungeonsweep.
You won't be getting into many team right now(and it's not as though there will be any chats where you will do better) but they are all about teaching you to become a better dungeoneer, which is primary for most low level dungeoneers. You are just weening into the teaming part of dungeoneering, so you'll have alot to learn.
-
I still can't understand people disregarding virtus. It's the 2nd best melee armor out there(for most things, basically because of healing and no negative melee) and clearly the best corp gear around(hand and shoulders above anything else). If anything, torva is the most useless set(as there is not much use for the higher defense).
-
First get p2p, then max out, and then train dungeoneering. Alternatively you can suck it up and train the way everyone does and not complain about a lack of knowledge(which is very much available from many sources) and levels(which clearly aren't very good, yet). If you are not willing to learn and improve yourself, dungeoneering really isn't a skill for you.
Blade, i think those calculations look pretty conclusive, yeah.
-
You guys need to take me on your PRO Nex trips i got all reqs and want to split but i always get a team where [bleep]ing noobs run >.>. oh well Willing to go
Willing to split am very trustworthy..but you will have to see for yourself
I don't see how there could be much trust in someone with 6 post count. If someone of the current tip teams cheated, they'd practically be excluded from these forums forever, which would be a big deal to them, can't trust people who have nothing to lose.
-
Getting 95 Prayer then doing the quest for turmoil?
Pro.
There are thousands upon thousands who have done that. Cheeesy wants to be special, too.
-
With Nex updated to be a little more realistic, has anything changed in how she's taken down?
focus is more on faster kills with smaller teams, since there is no killcount problem anymore
Thus meaning Void is more important now. Alright, thanks.
a great offense could be the best defense, atleast that's what grimy more or less found out. Doing the most damage isn't only about having the best offensive set, but when you can kill nex on max stats consistently(don't brew yourself to 0's). A divine could be as much of an offensive weapon as full void, at nex, and i'm still guessing that full pernix with divine would be the best setup possible.
As for large teams with lower levels, because of the specifics of nex, there are limits to how far you can push until you just can't outdamage her from what she heals in both blood stage and soul split stage, so really, there is no point in stupid masses.
-
So let me get this straight:
In Dungeoneering, you go out of your way to get max gear when it's in no way practical.
In overworld Runescape, you use crappy equipment because you're afraid of not being able to get back in 15 minutes.
Lolwut.
If you are referring to it being inconsistent in its statements then you should look at the problem from another angle
It always seems to go out of its way to prove the smart people wrong, so right now, it'd say it is being very much consistent in its own mind.
As for the bug, it's unbelievable that you got your stuff back, jagex should really test this stuff more(this is the second bug i've heard regarding nex'es nest/area).
-
Pretty sure all the pros soul split flick at DKs, seen multiple vids of it being done that way.
Not many do it while there are multiple DK's on them, and particularly when one of them is prime. If you screw up, it's highly likely that you'll die, thus it's not reccomended to risk it like that. I haven't seen many ss flick jad, for example.
-
At td's, you are supposed to ss flick when your first melee hit doesn't change prayer, so keep doing that.
At dk's, prime is just too dangerous to even think about flicking- it can go horribly wrong.
At frosts, you aren't taking any damage, and aren't even using curses, so i can't see any way you could use/need ss.
-
I'm the primal body on the left, the other primal body is are pro Primal Longsword stabber.
inb4hate
You do know primal longsword is the 4th best(or the worst with a stab option) stab weapon in daemonheim? Should tell people enough about your team...
-
Who in hell would want golvellius on his perm team when he is maxed and only skills? lugging him around for a whole dungeon would take in excess of 30 additional minutes for every singe dungeon, and even though he might not die(how could he, if he is not helping), his teammates would die more often because of him. I mean, who in their right mind would ever bind a primal pickaxe and then pretend to be helpful for the team.
I think the only way to remotely reduce door-lag is lowest graph setting- cuts it down to 1-2 seconds, and though it's still bad, it's somewhat more bearable. Definitely a major source of deaths, still.
-
*ponders the reasoning for asking in help and advice knowledge that hasn't happened yet*
In all seriousness we don't know the future. Common sense economics will say that as supply increases (more ways of getting prayer exp) and demand stays the same the price will go down. But none of us can know that demand will stay the same for any number of reasons so just have patience and wait to see.
Sure we can. The update provided more ways to get prayer experience without providing more reasons, so the net effect of this update is a drop in the price of prayer experience. Sure, some crazy thing might happen to raise prayer demand, but this update would still dampen the effect of that.
Put it this way- bone prices in the future will be lower than they would have been had this update not happened.
I don't think we have absolute confirmation about any place being worth it to gather ashes yet, and as the requirements are mostly high, there might not be a place where people make money off of them, as they would have much better moneymakers to consider. This update won't change prayer if there isn't alof of ash farmers, and i think it's fair to say there aren't yet. Long term, prices will come down, but be can't know how long term.
-
Yeah as people covered there is no "shortcut" to getting dg rewards.
The only way to get dg tokens is to earn 10xp per token inside dg.
So no matter what way you spin it you have to go get 340k xp inside dg.
Well, in actuality, you could get it in a relatively shorter time by training low level dungeoneering by methods other then dungeoneering(thus not wasting any time on it) and then train the needed 340k dungeoneering xp at a much faster pace. 340k takes alot of time at level one(more than 24 hours real time, i'm guessing) but could take less than an hour at 120(assuming you'd trained the skill by effigies or smth).
-
If doing Slayer with Overloads, eee is probably the best spec weapon. Its stupid wasting Prayer Points flashing SS if you could just 1click a Spec Bar and watch yourself heal. Using anything else for a Spec weapon is pretty stupid for the avg slayer task. I mean really, Claws? That gets you what, like 3 kills more p/h? At DKs and TDs though i'd stick with Claws as its easy enough to SS your way back to full LP and there high hitting specs are almost a must have.
People who use overloads for slayer don't generally care about money- they are doing it for speed, and they'd almost definitely use claws, or at times korasi, for spec. I think EEE is still worth it in a lot of places where you have risk and need to heal after overloading.
-
In kurdals dungeon, around 80% of the people(based on a couple of servers) don't do anything with the ashes that are dropped, some 10% use urns for them and just as many bank or yak them, so no, i wouldn't particularly say abyssals got much better with this update. People with 96 summoning can't bother with such a low moneymaker, and banking seems just too slow(fastest would be nech, but you could do perhaps 180 ash an hour with turt, whcih isn't much). Nothing groundbreaking, and the urns don't really help either(particularly if you are strapped for space).
Is anyone else just completely disappointed with everyone?
in General Discussion
Posted
If mods were educated enough(they actually played, no problem with that having atleast one highly educated mod on H&A) and worked swiftly enough in these situations, there really wouldn't be problems with this scenario other than people being outraged about being wrong, but that is something people need to learn.
Option 4 is actually best because it's most friendly for the OP- they won't even see the incorrect advice, thus there not being any confusion.