"The same moderator?" I'm sorry, but your story seems to have just fallen apart. How could they have not only known about this previous incident, but also been able to know the mdoerator who did the muting in sight, when there has been no indication whatsoever that anyone outside of your clan has spotted this moderator's name? Sure, you could have told him, but why would you? Your story just got fishier than a coral reef. Edit: The second mute was not made by the same mod. How would you know this? And can it be verified? If not.... It can not be verified, unless he was muted about 20 minutes ago with those other 2, he could not of been the one to mute; He was off world. We always warn people to stop autoing, it should never be a surprise when they get muted. I don't understand why he was muted for scamming, I will be questioning him on that though.