So I have a medium clue scroll that I got from the roaches. The first step was to talk to Caroline East of Ardy. She handed me a challenge scroll. I looked up the answer you have and it was wrong. How many fishermen are there on the fishing platform? Count them 11 ===== This is correct until you do Salt In the Wound quest. After that quest the answer to this (I went to platform) is zero. So perhaps we need a footnote on the entry? Thanks. I'd never get these blasted clues done if it wasn't for your treasure trail section :-D