I am in the middle of rocking out and whoever wrote the guide is incorrect...I was asked about the saucy wench first and that was the "heard of it? I was on it" response then when I was asked about the gnome's promise it wasn't that the ship was sunk, it was the other option being "of course i've heard of it, i'm a pirate"

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[pokemama edit: instead of claiming to be a mighty pirate, I told him I was a scurvy scallawag. So he asked me about Gnomes Promise (I was there) and then "The Reaver" (it sank). Did you say you were a might pirate? If so then we need some other folks to post - it may be different for everyone.]

#-o wish i read this before i done the quest, lol. i dont remember what exactly the guy asked me, but i do know that for me it wasnt the same as it was in the guide either. i just tried all options till i found the right ones for me

#-o wish i read this before i done the quest, lol. i dont remember what exactly the guy asked me, but i do know that for me it wasnt the same as it was in the guide either. i just tried all options till i found the right ones for me

 

 

 

 

 

:oops: Basically the same for me, but I'm more to blame because I was talking to another crewbie ABOUT the quest while doing it. I bet the correct answers is different for everyone.