Dming anyone 110+

[Promise]

My current stats are provided:

 

88 Attack

 

99 Strength

 

75 Defence

 

86 Magic

 

82 Range

 

91 Hit Points

 

70 Prayer

 

52 Summoning

 

 

 

 

 

The match will be held at duel arena. The rules will be as if we were fighting in the wilderness. Food, Potions, and Prayer will be turned on. Any combat styles are allowed, keep far casting to a minimal please. -.-

 

 

 

Just a small note, I'll probably record this and submit a video to the thread in General Discussion.

[Tuppatsch]

It realy depends on gear.

 

 

 

If both players were wearing str enhancing gear like bandos / str ammy / barrows gloves / dragon boots / gs

 

 

 

str would have an advantage.

 

 

 

where as if both were wearing defensive gear like full torags with crystal sheild fury ammy dragon guantlets (fog) and so on so forth

 

 

 

def would have the advantage.

 

 

 

but def also gets a general advantage, because it takes 4 def lvls for a combat lvl where as it takes 3 str lvls for a combat lvl.

 

 

 

so the acc with higher def will also have a little exta stats at the same combat lvl.

 

 

 

also rules like safing and stuff can easily effect the outcome.

[kudos6969]

str/attack will win because the way to get kills is using a DDS. Range, mage and def are all underpowered except for prehaps dark bow and dragon arrows but the cost of them and its one lucky spec compared to a 30k dragon dagger is silly.

 

 

 

btw my main character is 99 def 95 range 99 mage 80 str 81 attack so i understand what im talking about and when your 107 and a str+attack is 110 despite you having more levels for your combat your gonna get owned easily unless you get lucky and are also wearing about 50m in gear which you cant protect with prayer.

 

 

 

also bear in mind that it makes more sense to be wearing pkin gear to test it as its not really true if both players take all best items availible to them when that would only ever really happen in this case where your testing.

[Promise]

Ok, I see both of your points. I see your point about gear, so we would most likely wear a common outfit in Bh, such as rune. But on the other hand you could argue that every other person there has a red skull. We should just keep the gear as similar as possible.

 

 

 

I don't see how you could argue that attack and strength will always win. Have you seen my attack? It's a pitiful 88 (I think :lol: ) and my defence is a mere 75. Now I may have higher hits, but they will be inconsistent. Now lets compare it to someone with decent attack and strength, and a high defence. They'll probably be hitting the same as me, but will save a lot more food.

 

 

 

I also don't see how you could be using range and magic as your argument, if you've noticed, the title is str vs def. Also, safing won't really matter in a controlled environment like this. We'll both consume the same amount of food anyways.

[kudos6969]

 

I don't see how you could argue that attack and strength will always win. Have you seen my attack? It's a pitiful 88 (I think :lol: ) and my defence is a mere 75. Now I may have higher hits, but they will be inconsistent. Now lets compare it to someone with decent attack and strength, and a high defence. They'll probably be hitting the same as me, but will save a lot more food.

 

 

 

I also don't see how you could be using range and magic as your argument, if you've noticed, the title is str vs def. Also, safing won't really matter in a controlled environment like this. We'll both consume the same amount of food anyways.

 

 

 

in reality the whole point of having high defense is to use range and mage, there are very few who would use def with low attack and strength as a form of player killing simply because its just not good enough, you wont be able to ko. consistency isnt the problem its a simple case of str hits higher so has a greater chance of ko (40 followed by a 40 with whip or 4 specs of a dds all hitting high.)

 

 

 

the only time you may see a difference is with a strict rule of not running yes high defense may outlast the attack and str because he uses his food quicker but usualy at the point of 1-2 food left your opponent would run and the reason the fight was not decided was because noone got lucky with a string of high hits resulting in a ko. which of course the high attack and str had a greater chance of doing.

 

 

 

which is why i say that attack and str will always beat defense unless range and mage are used effectively and skillfully.

[Promise]

 

I don't see how you could argue that attack and strength will always win. Have you seen my attack? It's a pitiful 88 (I think :lol: ) and my defence is a mere 75. Now I may have higher hits, but they will be inconsistent. Now lets compare it to someone with decent attack and strength, and a high defence. They'll probably be hitting the same as me, but will save a lot more food.

 

 

 

I also don't see how you could be using range and magic as your argument, if you've noticed, the title is str vs def. Also, safing won't really matter in a controlled environment like this. We'll both consume the same amount of food anyways.

 

 

 

in reality the whole point of having high defense is to use range and mage, there are very few who would use def with low attack and strength as a form of player killing simply because its just not good enough, you wont be able to ko. consistency isnt the problem its a simple case of str hits higher so has a greater chance of ko (40 followed by a 40 with whip or 4 specs of a dds all hitting high.)

 

 

 

the only time you may see a difference is with a strict rule of not running yes high defense may outlast the attack and str because he uses his food quicker but usualy at the point of 1-2 food left your opponent would run and the reason the fight was not decided was because noone got lucky with a string of high hits resulting in a ko. which of course the high attack and str had a greater chance of doing.

 

 

 

which is why i say that attack and str will always beat defense unless range and mage are used effectively and skillfully.

 

 

 

 

 

Hmm, you have a good point there. I'll edit my original post. I'll fight anyone (range/mage tanks). Just keep farcasting to a minimal.

[edmasterx]

ill fight ya messgae me i got you added ill even stake 30k

[Promise]

ill fight ya messgae me i got you added ill even stake 30k

 

 

 

I made this thread on Jul 23...

 

 

 

You're lucky this forum isn't active yet or I'd probably lock this. This is called Grave Digging. Just for a future reference, and it's always a no-no. :shame:

 

 

 

You can sign up for the DMR if your interested in DMing though. Just note that it's still in its Beta Stages.