need a rough estimate on how m,uch exp/hour i can get whilst shilo fishing, i am 85 fishing atm, going for 99 and wonna see if it's more worth in shilo or at monks, thanks =3

At 90 fishing I got these results,

 

 

 

shilo : 36k xp per hour with something like 25-30k profit

 

 

 

monkfishs : 32k xp per hour with 105-110k profit per hour.

 

 

 

substract the cost of 2 fish potion for both.

 

 

 

Bear in mind that these were done without fishing boosting familiars...

I'm no expert but afaik:

 

for money -- monks>shilo

 

for xp -- barb rod fishing>shilo>monks