The Tip.it guide for this quest is incorrect.

It says you need to try and pickpocket father Urhney and then distract him by making some fires under his windows.

But you won't get the option to say 'fire! FIRE!', you must talk to Chief Thief Robin first, and when he tells you to make a fire under the window you will get the chat option.

 

It is really anoying to make a fire, and find out it doesn't work and then go back to Lumby castle and back to the shed to make a fire again.

Heya Ravenbloed, thanks for the submission.

 

I've done this quest a few times before following the guide, and I never had that issue so I quickly made a trial account then to test it out.

 

If you follow the guide directly as it is, you are right in saying that you don't get the 'fire' option. However, I was able to do it without talking to Darren Lightfinger and having him tell you to make a fire.

 

Instead, first talking to father Urhney seemed to be enough. For example, pickpocket, talk, light fire, talk again. That worked. As such, I've added the following sentence to that part of the guide: "Talk to him about the chalice."

 

Thanks for the submission, I've credited you for your help.

Thank you for changing the guide, I use Tip.it guides since 2004, best RuneScape fansite ever! :)

No worries, thanks for the submission! Glad you like the guides :).

 

I've locked this thread now to make it clear that it's all sorted, but if you ever notice anything else feel free to post a new thread or send me a pm.