no, to question on keeping him busy. that person would burn through food way to fast meaning you all would. it would be a very bad idea unless you give him super high def like torag and DFS. and for the magic def i said only the person who is getting attacked by boss uses it since he is using melee prayer. you still have the other 3 using verac. and id recommend karil not d hide since it has better mage def yea i kno about karil, was just thinking in case some members cudent get hold of it. But about the meler, if general attacks him will the mage attack him too? And another question , is ther a way to get the general to attack certain player? or is he random like zamorak boss