How about, instead of taking an existing skill and making that partially f2p, Jagex just takes the next updated skill and makes that skill partially f2p? It'd be pretty easy to determine what does and doesn't get put into f2p as pretty much everything probably needs to be added to the members world, too. However, there are a few drawbacks; 1. It will be awhile until a new skill is created, but odds are it will happen eventually, and since this arguement has pretty much been going on since p2p came out way back when, it can probably afford to wait awhile. 2. The skill may be connected with a p2p skill, which would make the skill completely useless to f2p players. Finally, if everyone continues to argue about this subject without finding a compromise, it can be gauranteed that jagex will do nothing. After all, why should they? Since there is a split opinion, they don't actually have to even care since it will most likely be more profitable to keep the skills p2p, and they don't risk a drop in popularity. If we can't agree on something, it will be the same as everyone deciding that it would be better if Jagex did nothing. Which, i suppose, is good for the people who don't want f2p to have anything else.