As far as broad bolts goes, they hit harder than knives/arrows generally. So, kill faster. Using knives until u can use broad bolts (60gp ea), should maximize ur exp. Idk bout ur profit tho. Slayer's profit is in the clue scrolls (in my opinion) until u can kill sara mages for d boots :) I wouldn't train controlled on whip unless you're no where close to 18m for a bando godsword (or ss if u have 7-8m) I would suggest u train att/str (dependin on which gs u'll ultimately want sgs or ags). Far as farming goes, buy watermelons to make supercompost (u can do this at lvl 1). You can use 4 buckets and sell 11 for (15x100=1500cost 11x500-600=5500-6600selling for 4k-5.1k profit per bin). Guams sell well (better than mar/tar) but any herb is good profit at ur lvl (seeds only 15-100ea). Plant marigolds or limps when u can for profit also. Dont use compost. Super will lessen chance for disease and boost harvests. I'll leave the cave fight advice for the pros. For smithing, check out the blast furnace guide. Smithing cannonballs is very slow. (varrock achievement armor will help speed smelting/smithing things a bit and gives u access to furnace by edge bank. closest in game) As a rule, smelting makes money and smithing wastes it (reverse this for experience). You can also do 'stealing creation' minigame for clay hammer (2x exp smithing) if u choose to smith. Hope this helps a bit