P2p does offer a lot more benefits for the smither than f2p. Selling steel bars is basically the only option for lower level smithers to make money from the smithing skill. The experience isn't great for it, but at least it doesn't cost you. P2p on the other hand can take those steel bars, turn them into cannonballs and make a profit - or they can make lower items like iron knives and smith them at breakeven cost, or making a profit. Not to mention the gold ores - I still remember Howdydee2003 and a few others all of us working gold ores before Jagex allowed people to change the gauntlets :P Smithing is a skill that will cost money unless you are prepared to put in a lot of work in supplying your own ores - especially on f2p... good luck on the skill though.