You agreed to a contract when you signed up to play Runescape. Now, you can bot all you want, but when you click that button to run your macro, that's your hand, not Jagex's. There's a difference between Jagex giving you reasons to bot and Jagex forcing you to bot. A person giving you reasons to hurt/kill them does not mean that it becomes ok to hurt/kill them.... Of course it doesn't, where did that come from? One of the arguments being presented here is that Jagex gives you reason to bot because the "game is boring." Even if that were true, which I don't feel it is, that is no excuse to bot. Much like a person giving you reason to hurt/kill them is no excuse to hurt/kill them. EDIT: Just to be clear, I was adding to your argument, not disagreeing :P.