Honestly I like both. On my first account I played back in '05 and '06, I really enjoyed the game, but never got too far into questing, the story, ect. All I really played Runescape for was to be able to talk with my friends on the phone and play with them. That is it. My account I use now I joined in September of 2015. I thought I wouldn't like RS3, but what do you know, I ended up loving it. It's where almost all of my hours playing are spent. It was a bumpy start with the new tutorial though, I didn't like starting in Ashdale and doing a quest vs. tutorial island. I didn't start playing OSRS until probably March of this year. While I love that they brought back the RS I (kinda) knew as a kid, I just don't like the people in the community that are CONSTANTLY bashing RS3. I NEVER see anyone in RS3 bashing OSRS. It makes OSRS's community seem kinda...hostile to me. It really drives me away from OSRS and sometimes I just don't want to get on because "If you like RS3, you're an idiot" (I've heard worse insults too, just didn't want to put them here. But I do really enjoy playing OSRS. I find it fun, and I love that even though it is an older version of RS, they still update it. Though I want to say one thing. "RS3 isn't the original RS." Where is your old account located? That is what I thought.