honestly, people who are calling carpentry crap, in my opinion, are fools. its not even out yet! people were calling farming crap. sure, it takes a while, but crap? definately not. i mean, when you have 50 ranar seeds, and u can get 5-9(?) per seed, that is alot of cash or herblore xp. as for carpentry, it aint even out yet. so dont call it crap. geez. i think it'd be good. Perhaps you could make poles, and, using smithing, attach metal heads, and voila, you have yourself a rune spear! and perhaps chairs could increase run energy fast. i mean, after a while, i kinda got sick of just standing in one spot getting fish, and occasionally having to move. of just standing there, clicking 1 monster and waiting for it to die. gets repetitive and boring after a while. with carpentry, who knows, people might actually have fun