i agree, jagex need to look after their f2p people. because all in all they are the members of tommorow. and if they lose interest in the game before they choose to become memb they never will. as for carpentry, it could go either way like farming did, personaly i find farming usefull, as you dont have to go out on trips to chaos monks for herbs then find the right ones when u can just grow them. But with carpentry the options for it are limited, i cant see it as a particularly profitable skill until you get to the extreme levels e.g 90 etc but it could be good, depends how much effort is put into its creation