WC guild is a good idea but most of you want it to fit to your own wants and not anyone elses. I see alot of people saying the req's should be what their lvl's are. You've got to be real: -Obvisouly the guild would work better as a P2P guild only, bringing in new members. -In a F2P guild the highest tree would be yews and the only other tree worth putting in would be willows. 2 trees in a guild is pointless especially when the autoers find a way around the safeguards (which they will find) -65 wc req as cutting yews lower than that is hard and even then it wont be easy with all the poeple there. -Another req too like fm or fletching would work best but then again not everyone uses those skills. A low req for fm wouldn't work because a low lvl auto-er could easily use normal logs and oak logs from cutting them to lvl up to get the fm, and fletching might work but when I was a mem I hardly used the skill and macroers could do the same as fm. So the only possible solution would be 50 (at the least, I'm thinking 58-60) fm or fletching. -To stop the macroers.... I like the random question thing but only you have to answer it everytime you go to the bank or the shop in the guild. I know it would be a hassle but it would slow down the macroers. The answers wouldn't be in the same place (like the princess/prince-frog random, my 2nd time I automatically went to where I thought the Yes was going to be but instead clicked No). And it would only be like 5 (10 tops) very simple questions. -NO mini games or token crap. this a guild not some other place to add more stuff. -6 through 8 magic trees -8 or 9 through 12 or 13 yew trees I honestly don't care about the rest as I would only cut magic/yew and maybe willow or maples (81 wc, 71 fm, and 13 fletch for now). But obvisouly there would be other trees like mahogany and maple trees. Also they would have to make like a woodcutters gloves or quest becuase the cook guild needs a chef hat and crafting needs a brown apron. I'm thinking Woodcutters gloves (or maybe even a new axe) where it counts the number of logs cut and after a certain amount you have to recharge it in the guild. You'd have to do something for it like a quest or... or something. It'd help with the macroers a bit too. (If you can come up with something better then lets here it) This obvisouly wouldn't be excatly as it is. But when you all agree you have the perfect idea then everyone should just bombard Jagex with the suggestion/idea. If enough people told them I think they might do something about it. It'd work even better if we could get on of them to agree with us and help out too. This is how I think it should be, don't go hating me if you don't agree on something. Feel free to coment on this. RS name: Raymundo 3rd
