Heh, heres another planet sig. I took the planet off of one of my submissions that I made on deviant art http://www.deviantart.com/view/13117855/

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

That's nice Eric. Especially your deviation. 9/10 man. :)

Thx dood =-)

Nice, deviantart seems to be down though. :(

The link works for me just fine. Hrmph. The dev. is way better than the sig. Planet ring and everything lol.

The link works for me just fine. Hrmph. The dev. is way better than the sig. Planet ring and everything lol.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

It's up again, looks nice. :-)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

9/10 as there are no stars. :P

Id tell you what I think, but its on the down side if you know what I mean... Don't want banned for saying it... 3/10

It doesn't look like a planet. It has no Depth whats so ever, and although i do like the typo somewhat (the sig maker part, no) The sig seems way to empty and flat to be catagorized as a space/planet sig. Infact, if you didn't say it was a planet some may have not been able to tell it was :shock:

It doesn't look like a planet. It has no Depth whats so ever, and although i do like the typo somewhat (the sig maker part, no) The sig seems way to empty and flat to be catagorized as a space/planet sig. Infact, if you didn't say it was a planet some may have not been able to tell it was :shock:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1st, the title of the topic is Rate the planet sig, second, I just ripped a peice off of my dev entry that you probably didnt even look at, third, Im a begginer at planets, so dont get you pannies in a wad.

Don't argue with Nad on this stuff, he knows his stuff. If you haven't checked out his and Ryan's shop maybe you should and you'll see what I'm saying. So on that note I'm in full agreement with nad.

Ill have to agree with nad. Also it seems that the planet takes up to much of the sig. You also should have stars that would make it look a lot better, and work on the text it doesnt seem to work with the sig and its too dark.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

edit: I just checked the deviation that looks really nice mabye try taking a different part for the sig.

 

 

 

I rate the deviation a 10/10.

adding stars is not good because if there's a sun anywhere in that galaxy stars wouldn't be seen in the immediate atmosphere of the planet, which seems to be a gas giant, meaning it has a thick atmosphere.

ok...i checked the devart pic and it still stinks....all it is...3 planets liined up and stars in the bg...all stars are the exact same...4/10

*brings the jealousy* Why not go with 1 hit? have to say nad... lol

Heh, thanks again for all of the critisism. I really enjoy being flamed :? . And im not arguing with nad, i know he is really great at sig making, I just dont appreciate him flaming me for somthing that im new at. Did I mention this is my second planet that Ive ever done?

No one flamed you... It's called constructive criticism... If you can't handle it don't post... You just are not liking what your hearing, so don't get mad...

Yeah I guess your right, but please, instead saying "its boring and flat" or "it has no depth whats so ever," give me suggestions on what I can do to fix it or make it to where I dont need constructive critisism. +)

adding stars is not good because if there's a sun anywhere in that galaxy stars wouldn't be seen in the immediate atmosphere of the planet, which seems to be a gas giant, meaning it has a thick atmosphere.

 

 

 

ya ya i understand but like i said take a different part from the deviation so that it is like half planet and half space so there would be enough space to have stars.

thanks for the suggestions sluchie :P ^^