apparently barb fishing is better xp but,

 

is it still faster if i cut every fish and droppinng their roe or caviar,

 

or is shilo village faster with me banking the fish and then cooking them later

There is not much diffrence in experience. And with Shilo you CAN cook the fish afterwards which makes it even better.

well i found out i did not need to drop roe and caviar, i can use it as bait, so i think barb fish is sure to be faster

Yep barb is faster

Barb is only faster if you concentrate fully on it i've heard.

if u have actually done it, it doesnt need a lot more concentration then normal fishing

Barb:

 

Pro: Faster Fishing XP

 

Cons: Virtually no cooking XP

 

 

 

Shilo:

 

Pro: For every XP in fishing you also get in cooking

 

Cons: Slightly slower than barb fishing

 

 

 

Take your pick ;)