Which is better money and exp:

 

Lobbies vs. Swordies + Tuna (without the gloves)

 

 

 

and

 

 

 

Lobbies vs. Swordies + Tuna (with the gloves)

 

 

 

assuming both are at the same place (karjama)

Which is better money and exp:

 

Lobbies vs. Swordies + Tuna (without the gloves)

 

 

 

and

 

 

 

Lobbies vs. Swordies + Tuna (with the gloves)

 

 

 

assuming both are at the same place (karjama)

 

 

 

Xp and cash are both actually quite close at 99 fishing. For earlier levels, lobbies are probably better xp and cash, though i can't really test for you, and prices where so much different back when i was lower level.

 

 

 

My advice is to do lobsters, from the choices.

 

 

 

As for the gloves, i do not know for sure, however i'm pretty sure the time spent fogging will make it slower overall in every respect. So unless you really enjoy fog, and would be doing it anyway, don't bother with the gloves.

I found fishing swordfish with gloves was quite good for exp, as i got from lvl68 - 72 fishing doing that, and the cash is quite good, but slow.

Getting the swordfish gloves is a waste of time, but if you have them already, swordfish will probably beat out lobsters exp-wise. So if you're going to play FoG whether it's efficient or not, swordfish are best if you don't care about money.

 

 

 

Lobsters are faster money.