I'm opening this for the veteran runescape players, such as myself, but if you're a newer player with some knowledge of RSC feel free to post. In order for this debate to work, I'm going to have to set a time(or your own) for the new age versus old. Old age includes RSC and the transition period is the first few months of rs2. New age is obviously from then on :mellow:

 

Which time period did you enjoy playing runescape the most?

Fatigue version 2. When you could drunkenly thieve using a cocktail shaker.

I was pissed when they fixed the cocktail shaker :(

 

The next best time was directly after the release of Legends. I was level 65 at the time, and was the lowest level legend around.