Whoa!!! Comparing sharks to magic logs, I'd say sharks definitely win. Just because something is the highest in a skill doesn't mean its better than something that is not the highest in its respective skill. But if u compared manta rays, highest in fishing, Id say mages are better. Well both Shark and Magic Logs are used mostly for the money. 100 Shark = 88k 100 Magic Logs = 120k I think that kinda proves my point. As you can see Magic logs have a huge price difference then Shark. 100 Monkfish = 34k 100 Yew Logs = 40k There is only a 6k price difference each 100 Monkfish. Thats why I say there both Skills are equal to each other it just depends on what YOU like the most. And you got to remember you fish Monkfish faster then you cut Yew Logs and cut Magic Logs faster then you fish Shark.