The whip is current the 3rd best weapon in the game (not counting damonhiem), Rapier being in first, CLS being about as efficient, but winning at a few places. If that isn't close to the best, idk what is. The Primal Maul is horrible, good luck going through 5:5 dungeons infested with level 100+ zombies when all you can do is crush. It should be a given that chaotics are the best And no [cabbage] about the claws...the spec is the reason people buy them, and why they're so good to use. The Primal maul is currentley the strongest weapon in the game... Says on RS Wikia (official wikipedia for RS) plus you need 99 strength to wield...clearly the best weapo in the game, because you need 99 strength, and it says o various websites. Plus I'm allowed to have my own opinion on d claws.