Great charms, effigies, decent xp (well ok, only 32k/hr at the current off-task rates, ignoring dreadnips) and break-even... skip? Just because you don't get melee xp (except a little defence) doesn't mean they are a bad task. Charms don't really justify them as being good otherwise you could say the same thing for waterfiends which should be skipped. Effigies, meh the chance in getting one in 20-30 kills is pretty rare so again, no. Swithing to mage gear just for that is also a hassle and too much of an overkill. - skip I belive effigies are 1/150 for miths? (My rate is bout 1/120 atm, but I'm lucky, and havn't killed thousands of them..) A 1/5 chance of getting an effigy off a mith task isn't that bad imo, consideringg that it's a sub 20 min task But you have to switch gear and spellbook