For gods sake, I'll lay this out. He wouldn't be using jugs of wine, flowers etc. Auto retalliate off would work just fine. It doesn't matter if he isn't hitting the monster, and the monster is hitting him, the recoil will do damage, and kill the monster. He CAN'T use tears of guthix to get slayer levels. Because his combat skills are his lowest levels, the experience from the minigame would be given to one of those, thus raising combat. I believe he posted on Rsbandb a while ago that he raised it through Genies + Recoil rings. Simple, no?