I just got void knight melee helmet today to complete my set (just missing the mace), after play pest control the first time in a while. I used the Runehq calculator to see if it's better with 82 str, and +99 str bonus, than with 82 str and +114 str bonus with no void set.

 

 

 

It was. Then, I checked on Tip.it, and it was just as good as 15 extra str bonus without the melee set's bonus!

 

 

 

Help please? Seriously, what's going on? The calculators are giving two different results, and I don't know which to trust. So can someone tell me which is correct, or how the bonus works so I can figure it out myself?

 

 

 

Thanks in advance!

The tip.it max hit calc often gives a result that will be 1 damage higher than what you actually can do. Either way, Void melee is better offensively since you also get the 10% attack bonus ;)

 

 

 

EDIT: When using the tip.it calc on for the void set's max hit, it is actually correct more often than not ;) . Just remember, if you don't trust the calcs, you can just test it yourself ;)

The tip.it max hit calc often gives a result that will be 1 damage higher than what you actually can do. Either way, Void melee is better offensively since you also get the 10% attack bonus ;)

 

 

 

EDIT: When using the tip.it calc on for the void set's max hit, it is actually correct more often than not ;) . Just remember, if you don't trust the calcs, you can just test it yourself ;)

 

 

 

;) ;) ;) ;) ;) ;) ;) ;) ;) ;) ;) ;) ;)

Tip.it > RuneHq

I think i trust Runehq on this one. Tip.it calculated as if it increased the str bonus by 10%, and Runehq calculated as if it increased the damage done by 10%. According to the Runescape KB, it increases damage by 10%.

 

 

 

I'll just keep testing, I only got to test for a few minutes.