I'm trying to do fairytale part 2, and need the herblore req. What is the cheapest potion(s) to make between level 46 and 57? Of course, if the cheapest option is something so slow that the weekly exp from tears would be better, please don't post it :P. Thanks!

Post questions and suggestions below, please.

Cheapest way is farming your herbs. Usually profits.

Cheapest way is farming your herbs. Usually profits.

Alright, whats the amount of time I'm looking at to farm and make all the potions, and what herbs/potions should I use?

About a week of farming them often (every 90 minutes or so).

Sorry but I'm really too tired to work out how long or what ones you should farm.

you can also MTK your herbs and not sell any of your herb drops as well

Energy potions are the cheapest potion to make, coming in at 14.9 gp/xp. You need 133,341 xp for 57 herblore, so that should cost 1,986,780. If you farm ranarrs (the most profitable herb), and 4 patches survive, and you do 3 runs per day, you'll earn 379k gp. You'll only need to farm for a little over 5 days. So, in essence, buy ranarr seeds, farm ranarr, sell ranarr, buy harrlander/chocolate dust, make energy potions, hope energy potions sell.

haha cool, thanks.

(sorry for the super late reply, i got grounded... :( )