Well personally, I see no harm to try it out. Under the conditions Peter has mentioned, it might work well. As long as it didn't turn into a popularity contest, it might have some worthwhile. But I'm on the fence with it. Tip.it has seemed to function well enough without it in the past, would it be totally needed? Would it create a better atmosphere to the forums? As the Admins know, all those questions should be taken into consideration. :) I am interested to see how the discussion goes.