I'm a 20 days old f2p, but this guide is rubbish, I can tell.... I got 40 in crafting on my first day, and this is how I get it quick and smart. Lvl 1 - 28 or 40: Mine the north clay in Varrock SW mine, bank. Take 14 buckets, and 14 clays. Wet them in edgeville, bank the wet clay. Edgeville-> barbarian village, make the highest lvl thing you can, at lvl 8 you get bowls. Lvl 28 - 40: Kill cows :) .. good for newbie like me to raise a bit of combat. make hard leathers, you know how. Now crafting guild. I think the guild should be use in 3 methods. 1. Crafting + Combat exp 1a) want money -> sell at rimmington general store 1b) lose money + quicker exp -> drop 2. Only Crafting exp but gain and lose no money CLAY ! Very good exp there, and you can stay there for months (drop gems) 3. Mine ores Silver: Al Kharid mine is better, you can smelt on your way back and is nearer to bank, just one rock less Gold: Crafting Guild is good but it give poor crafting exp, but good money if you sell gold ores to members, whom will use them to gain 2nd fastest smithing exp per hour Summary: So.. basically your guide is not very useful, along with some major errors, for example: Tiaras do not sell for good money unless you think 10gp ea is good. Bring the mould is a waste of slot for you need to walk one more trip each 28/27 trips you do. Al Kharid Furnance is much closer than Faladors. Speed is more important than exp given, if you do other methods twice quicker, its pointless to care about 35exp or 52.5 EACH.