Finally decided to get imbued rings.

 

I plan on getting both if not all of the rings, but I was wondering which would make a bigger difference.

 

I know I'll hit higher with the Beserker but to be honest hitting like 2-3 higher really don't appeal to me that much unless the extra attack from Warrior doesn't help as much.

I'd get Onyx (i), a good spread of attack bonuses, only a tiny bit worse than Warrior, probably un-noticable. But with the recent changes, it'd be hard to get the Onyx ring in the first place.

Berserker and Onyx is probably best, since you'll have a ring for ranging/maging/non-slash melee.

Onyx, it's good for everything, and also archer/seers. The only three rings anyone really needs. I personally have those three and the zerker, but thats because i'm paranoid about my strength bonus, hence f cape + bandos instead of skillcape and barrows.

onyx ring is usually better, but every now and then u'll run into slayer tasks with ridiculously low defense

 

IE dust devils and fire giants. Those are the only tasks i personally use berserker(i) over onyx