hey guys, which is better all around, whip or Zamorak Spear?

Whip, ZS only for corp beast or waterfiends.

whip

so then is the zamorak spear better for anything? if so, why?

Corp and waterfiends, dragons with super antifires, especially metals.

so then is the zamorak spear better for anything? if so, why?

 

Best for corp because non-spear weapon damage is halved.

 

Good for Wfs because they are weak to crush

 

Good for metal/colored dragons if you have super antifire and no chaotic rapier

Also useful for knocking people around in Castle Wars with its special attack.

Overall whip ftw zammy in situations stated above

Yup, a whip combined with a rune defender > ZS. ZS does have a one huge advantage though, crush. Great for waterfiends.