I agree with this solution EXCEPT for one thing. The immunity to ranged and magic. Ranged still has to use black armor, which lowers its stats, and black weaponry, i.e. the knives and darts. Magic also has to use black armor which DRASTICALLY lowers its stats. But a mage can use far more powerful spells such as ancients. Therefore, the Wraith should have boosted defenses against magic, but no immunity to any combat style. Edit: An easy solution to this, and all loot stealing, is to do what WoW does. The person, or team, who lands the first blow gets the loot. It doesn't matter how much damage you deal, if you weren't first, you get no loot. Umm, that's called single way combat in Runescape.