Kyle85

ok, I added a border, so it may or may not look any better.

Well this is my first and I loosly followed a tut, although I severely messed it up. anyhow, rate it comments are appreciated as well. Also, what is the best way to add a border to it through photoshop

Well other than the fact that the text is a little tough to read I think it looks pretty alright. Maybe add alittle more color to that big black spot on the right side.

Well then, I would like one. Can be of anything you like, but I would prefer it to have to do with halloween, and non rs oriented. Also the if the words, Athens 2004, biggest halloween party in America, could be added to the sig without making it look horrible that would be swell.

use the test topic next time and you wont get such a harsh response.

well Im no pro at animation by any means I think if you added more frames it might end up a little smoother.

Harry, FYI, your sig is too big. it should only be 300x150, yours is 330x152

one you have now

it just looks like you inverted the colors.

Ok first of all I dont think calling anyone a bastard is appropriate, let alone needed. Second of all did I ever say that I didnt like it? I know that it took some time to draw, what I was implying was that if anyone decided to spend about 20 minutes of their life to try something that they could make something like this also. Oh and when I feel like making sigs I always try to come up with my own ideas. So no, you will not be seeing me making one of these sigs.

no, it just sorta looked cluttered. By the way, learn to take criticsm. You come off sounding like a jerk.

God Slayer, one thing I noticed about your sig is your guy seems to be able to fly he is so far off the dock. When I first say your outline I thought that it was gonna a closer view with the shark being huge and the dock being a lot closer. Well that and your face looks kinda wierd.

Um....is there some point to that picture?

Umm....Maybe practice a little yourself?

um....you didnt put a whole lot of effort in it did you? 2/10. I gave you this rating becasue all you did was add text and put your head from the game on some guy in a picture of what seems to be a group of rappers?

Craters on the moon are too uniform. they are not perfect looking circles. Also where is that mountain shadow coming from? I think that when I looked really really close I thought I saw the mountain, but if there really is one, it is way too dark.

ok, so this is a good example of people just buying the name. No offense or nothing, but I think even I could make one of those.

cananon balls can too stack like that. have you ever seen movies where there is a pyramid of cannonballs?

why are you using thought bubbles to show speach?

wow, that is beutiful. If I had a couple million Id blow it on this sig. You wouldnt happen to have a layaway program would you :wink:

never said you couldnt, just pointed out that you didnt do people good.

What the chunk?! Ive been messin around in photoshop for about a week and a half now, but I cant make anything anywhere close to that. Could you tell me where you got the tutorials please? Also your sig looks good, bt you make wanna try a small, lighter font and font color.

Ill bid a rune scmitty and whatever little money i have on number six.

doesnt exactly seem like you do people too well either

(My first critique in about six months. Where does the time go.) The sig is a little small, I couldn't really see the lines in the center until I got about an inch from the screen. As pretty much everyone else said the lens flare has to go. And finally add a border. You'd be amazed at how much better sigs look when they have a border.