Does not Veracs armor have the lowest slash defence than the other melee brothers? I would guess him, but I never tried to melee anybody besides karil and ahrim...

 

 

 

Verac has the worst MAGIC defence imo :

 

 

 

no he actually has better mage defense then the other melee sets I believe :P

 

 

 

And yeah he has less slash defense since his torso is mostly exposed and it's easier to hack him open there :twisted:

 

But his flail just hits really hard on you so he isn't easy to heal on :(

dh just got p0wned by my bronze daggers wo0t z0mg i'm so godly! dh you weak you can only hurt me when your cuts get cuts!

 

 

 

I don't melee bros, I'm a magican

If we're not worrying about damage taken, then I would say Verac. I seem to hit him with my whip (like in tunnel and he pops up) quite often. I find it hard to heal with Guthans on any of the melee brothers, I was able to do it on Guthan once and ended up with nearly full hp but it took a couple minutes. I find Guthan is hard to melee, even with Veracs sometimes. I would say Veracs if them attacking back isn't a problem.

 

 

 

If we're talking about with prayer, I'd say Torag, I never hit Guthan for some reason, but can hit Torag quite a bit. Plus Torag can't heal.

 

 

 

If we're talking about meleeing without prayer, damage being taken... Torag also. I always seem to get hit with 20+ hits from Guthan. I usually get hit 0 0 0 23 21 0 19 or something. He rarely hits low on me, it's either nothing or high. Torag can do that sometimes on a bad day but not as often. So Torag again.