watcha think?

quite nice but looks liek you didnt take you much time in doing it.

 

 

 

even though i cant do it looks very simple so i will rate 5/10

more comments welcome

simple but effective, work on linework :wink: 7/10

cmon guys & girls, i need to know where i hav slacked and where i hav done good :lol:

Linework seems a bit sloppy, but the lighting is wonderful.

the fire seems to use a lens flare... a nice job.

 

 

 

8/10 8)

the lighting on the fence seems horrible to me. there will just be a shaded one ever third part.

need something besides the fire...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

lookes pretty empty upfront

i know :?

 

 

 

couldnt think of anything to put there but i may add sumthin if i get any suggestions? :P

I agree with the previous comment. Your biggest mistake was not thinking out a total theme at the start. But I know the feeling :)

Yea i hate not planning sigs to a certain extent they usually turn out bad, but in this case i think it turn out ok, not great but ok, theres still sumthin IMPORTANT missing but i cant put my finger on it...

Yah I should note that what you have there is well done, just doesn't really hit ya due to lack of content. But the shading is nice in any case.

pretty cool :P no suggestions :(

i seriously sat there today in skewl for about 20 mins thinking of something to put in it, my mind was blank, got home sat here for another 10 mins thikning, again nothing, i will carry on thinking until my mind is well...lol :lol: