You didn't have to quote the whole thing...

 

 

 

 

 

And support. Very good idea.

Sorry about that.

I can't say I support because it would severely kill the raw material market due to the vast flow of supplies coming from these low-competition areas.

I like the idea... But I have a problem with the "Blacksmiths and the Tannery", I don't think jagex would like this idea because its near a bank.

Support. looks like an interesting idea

Well, I can see you invested some time in this, and the idea in general has potential.

 

 

 

A few problem that prevent me from supporing:

 

1.It seems that skilling in here would be too easy. That's a major problem, especially since rocks and a tanner are so close to a bank.

 

2.You need to fish your fish and then release them so that your clan could fish these all over again? Or did I get it wrong? If I didn't, then Fishing should not be a part of this suggestion.

 

3.What if I kill the monsters there? Do they respawn? Do I get drops? How hard is it to add monsters to my CV?

 

4.You had way too many "maybe"s in your post. You should read it again, I don't like reading a post of someone who's not sure his suggestion deserves to be written. I can see why you would have trouble thinking about SOME things, I can see why you'd add a "maybe" every now and then, but you can't expect me, or the readers to decide on everything.

 

5.How would clan competitions work? Are they scheduled by JaGeX, or are those spontaneous, and decided on by players/clans?

 

6.What about the trophies? How hard is it to achieve any?

 

7.How do skill competitions work?

 

8.Are trophies unique, or can any clan win any trophy by winning a certain competition? If so, how many and what types of trophies are there?

 

 

 

Meh, too many problems than I thought I had in mind. But if you can solve all of these, count me in ;) .