I've been claiming the 5 horns regularly for donating 30k to the alliance, but according to some alliance members this doesn't add to the alliance and you're paying 30k for 5 horns?

 

I won't be able to check until tomorrow and meaning I could be wasting 30k, so I thought I best ask here.

Every time you do it, you deduct 30k gold from the alliance. That means if you donate 30k gold, then do the task, the alliance gains nothing however you gain 5 horns and lose 30k gold.

 

Yes it is a useless task, and do not do it.

Wow, thank god I always give 30k a day.

Every time you do it, you deduct 30k gold from the alliance. That means if you donate 30k gold, then do the task, the alliance gains nothing however you gain 5 horns and lose 30k gold.

 

Yes it is a useless task, and do not do it.

I tryed it, you're wrong. It only takes away contribution but not the spent gold.