So in about a week i will be getting 120 dg, and thus i will be able to cancel dg tasks from the gal in burthrope. 

 

My question, which daily challenges are the best to keep un blocked. 

 

I would probably like to do either a gathering skill or even dg still. would farming be a good one to keep, it is quick and farm runs are not bad to do

 

~~~legoman187~~~

Divination
Agility
Runecrafting
Dungeoneering

 

are all fairly common.

 

Reasoning: The first three are the three slowest skills in the game, and dungeoneering is fairly dead if you don't have a permanent team and are looking to get 200m (also do sinkholes).

Best to worst:

 

Runecrafting

Divination

Agility

Dungeoneering

 

There's a pretty significant drop-off between divination and agility. Personally I have runecrafting, divination, and dungeoneering unblocked because I have a tendency to disappear for a few days at a time. Sinkholes are lower xp/hour than dg challenges (I think), but it's worth doing them and rc/div challenges instead.

 

I think Bxpprod tested crafting challenges, but I forget what his conclusion was.

I'm in a similar situation, however, i'd like to add another twist to the question- the time it takes to complete the challenge. As far as i looked, farming(plant a herb) and prayer(bury 5 bones) seemed very fast, but is there anything better? Also, is there somewhere an xp table for the rewards?

You want to look at the marginal time it takes to complete the challenge

 

For example, runespan is 100% efficient, so you only need to count the time it takes to get to runespan. The same goes for the divination challenges.

 

Slayer is also one of the fastest, but it doesn't give a good payout. I think it might actually be the highest marginal xp/hour, but it'd take forever to get a decent amount of xp from it.

Crafting is ~47k xp (think it's 46880 but cant remember, can't be assed) for the time it takes to buy an rune 70 uncharged decorated cooking urns. Not that while it says make blah blah blah, just buying the uncharged and filling them with runes works a treat. Think it costs roughly 100k also.

 

Do your numbers from there because I don't particularly know what numbers to use for crafting since...lolcrafting

Yeah it's probably about equal to rc/div then

You want to look at the marginal time it takes to complete the challenge

 

For example, runespan is 100% efficient, so you only need to count the time it takes to get to runespan. The same goes for the divination challenges.

 

Slayer is also one of the fastest, but it doesn't give a good payout. I think it might actually be the highest marginal xp/hour, but it'd take forever to get a decent amount of xp from it.

I usually only play an hour or less a day, so that may sometimes be in the consideration. I also can't be arsed to do anything i don't enjoy in scape, and 20 minutes of agility every day would kill me. If you don't value the xp past 99 very high, you are basically stuck with doing things you hate for the little time that you do play. Basically, you are accounting the real world method as 100% efficient and i'd like you to consider the challenge itself as the 100% efficient method(which it usually is).

 

What is the payout on slayer? Given that it is one thing i do enjoy in scape.

Dungeoneering challenges take like 2-3 minutes. Runespan can be closer to 15-20ish, but it's really afk. You'd like it. Slayer is like 8k xp, so don't bother.

so the answer is keep either dg or farming up. ok that is the plan

~~~legoman187~~~

Dungeoneering challenges take like 2-3 minutes. Runespan can be closer to 15-20ish, but it's really afk. You'd like it. Slayer is like 8k xp, so don't bother.

I hate afking in scape. 8k sounds really low yeah. I'll likely continue with dg challenges, but will look into what the rewards for farming/prayer are(given that those only take 10 seconds to complete).

From memory (again someone can surely do this who isn't me because I don't want to waste a day) the reward for farming is ~4.5k xp. Hardly even worth thinking about.

But it is fast, i don't terribly care about xp, once i get comp i will be doing clues and trim reqs. if i get xp yay. if not no big deal. (no efficiency arguments here please it is a game after all)

 

~~~legoman187~~~

Then that contradicts your original post. What do you clarify as "the best" because from what I can tell, farming is far from it. It isn't worth keeping. That answers your original question as I read it - how do  you mean for it to be interpreted 

Then that contradicts your original post. What do you clarify as "the best" because from what I can tell, farming is far from it. It isn't worth keeping. That answers your original question as I read it - how do  you mean for it to be interpreted 

As i brought out, there are multiple ways to look at this. Right now, you are basing it on the notion that a real world method is 100% efficient and you are going for 200m all skills. However, If you consider the challenge itself as the 100% efficient method, the lineup will undoubtedly change(basically you consider yourself getting 200m in a skill solely with challenges).

Then that contradicts your original post. What do you clarify as "the best" because from what I can tell, farming is far from it. It isn't worth keeping. That answers your original question as I read it - how do  you mean for it to be interpreted 

And you specify the best for him as in terms of xp efficiency. What if his best is in terms of time to do a challenge?

 

Then that contradicts your original post. What do you clarify as "the best" because from what I can tell, farming is far from it. It isn't worth keeping. That answers your original question as I read it - how do  you mean for it to be interpreted 

And you specify the best for him as in terms of xp efficiency. What if his best is in terms of time to do a challenge?

 

 

Then he would answer my question as I posted it, saying exactly that, wouldn't he.

 

OH MAYBE NOT.

There are 2 kinds of efficiency: productive and allocative

 

They have slightly different definitions outside runescape, but this is how I define them for this purpose:

 

Productive: xp/hour of 1 method / xp/hour of another. Basically gives you how much you produce relative to how much you could have produced.

 

Allocative: % of goal achieved / time that could be spent achieving goal. Basically says that getting 4.5k farming xp per day is a bad idea even if it's good xp/hour because it'd take over a century to get 200m. 1 hour of vinesweeper gets you like 2.5 weeks worth of farming challenges.

i meant time and ease of doing it. i don't really wish to do agility rc or div as they do not really help me with my future goals. 

 

farming is less than a minute and dg is less than 5. that is what i am going with. 

 

tbh i wanted the efficient answer so that i know what i could be doing. i am going to do the inefficient one because simply i can, also the efficient ones are not fun in my mind, sans the dg one. 

 

~~~legoman187~~~

Well then, strictly in terms of time spent doing it, Crafting is also exceptionally fast and thus worth considering. Time it takes to buy and fill 70 urns ~1 minute.

Yeah do crafting.