In your opinion what is your best armor against magic based melee attack monster regardless of the money spend on them?

 

 

 

PS.: Not counting with the Guthan armor (not using his special at least).

I assume you mean a monster like jellies, bloodvelds, etc.

 

A good setup IMO would be this [if you're going to attack with melee. but the best way to go would be to safespot range.]

 

Bezerker helm, your best cape and amulet, wizard boots/infinity boots/rune boots, black dragonhide body and chaps, barrows gloves, bezerker/warrior/seers ring, rune defender/prayer book/elemental shield, your best weapon. Or you could hally them..

What do you think about Karil's armor?

 

It has better magic defence then black dragon hide armor.

 

 

 

And how about Bearhead helm, Seer ring, Fire cape, Gods capes, Amulet of fury, Mind helm and Mind shield?

Well, I didn't mention karils as I don't see it as worth it, due to the repair necessary. I'm not sure about how good bearhead is.. And I suggested bezerker helm because of strength bonus.

 

And when I said 'elemental shield' I meant mind, but I forgot the name. Basically what you wear has to do with how rich you are.

Yes Bear Head has best (?) magic def for a helmet I believe.

So against this monsters what do you think is better:

 

Only magic defence (as high as possible)

 

Or (magic + melee) defence as high as possible ?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I ask this because magic and melee prayers both work against them.

Magic defence as high as possible, but also try to get some good attack bonuses.

magic prayers don't work against them =; i mean its magic based melee