Just like you rationalize us criticizing the site for us being Jagex/Ivp fanboys? Just like how you rationalize it so that it means what you want it to mean? Also, if you read the thread you'd realize something. Many people WANT this to be correct, because it echoes the players sentiments and what they think. I'd even go so far as to say most. However, as much as people might want it to be true, you need to look at it objectively as well. Statistical evidence > personal anecdotes, despite the fact that the human brain instinctively chooses anecdotes over statistics. Is the sample size large enough to be considered accurate, especially when you take out the fakes and maybe fakes? I honestly don't know, and I highly doubt you do either. The way I "rationalize" this thread is that most players want it to be true, but are being cautious about it. They aren't willing to immediately claim that this site is the evidence they are looking for despite it saying exactly what they want it to say.