'Highlander' (Skill lol)

[dv_trainer]

GUESS WUT?

 

 

 

You're a [bleep]ing jerk =D> :thumbsup:

[BloodArgon]

I'm so glad that I gave up on the suggestion after starting the FIRST [bleep] update. What a waste of time.

 

 

 

You've really shattered my respect of the Tip.It forums

 

Respect?

 

This is just a poorly written idea.

 

And a poor idea.

 

 

 

You cant just toss garbage in front of me and expect it to be called art.

 

And you can't just look at a post and call it garbage simply because it is a work in progress

 

 

 

Then put it in notepad and make sure its written out before you post it on here.

 

Doing it before hand for 'early criticism' just gives you what you got here; trash.

[Outsanity]

Now to summarise the annoyance with a simple statement taken (and edited - short etc) by me:

 

 

This is an extremely short, but still in progress suggestion for an Legendary Skill. I have, to the best of my ability, made sure not to suggest anything overpowered or unrealistic. My goal is to show people the potential this skill could possess if done correctly. I can only hope, that as you read through this, you will find yourself wanting the skill to be real, as I have for a while now.

 

 

 

Also, please, do not post on this thread unless you have thoroughly read through ALL of the post. It is short, yes, but I want intelligent posts with comments and construction criticism.

 

 

 

Please no flaming. No rude behavior. No foul language. Follow ALL of Tip It's Forum rules, and then some.

 

 

 

 

First of all, I suggest you watch out, because if I were a big enough jerk I could call you out on plagarism for using my words and changing the meaning by replacing "Archaeology" with "Legendary" and "well thought out" with "still in progress". First off, I don't condone this god awful skill, so I suggest you change your post and don't quote me as if I said all that relating to your skill. Secondly, my skill is not work in progress. I know you were trying to get a point across, but you quoted me as saying that, which I did not. And thirdly, how dare you try to throw my own work back at me just because yours is actually garbage?

 

 

 

I'm not flaming, I'm telling you the entire roots in which this idea exist are rotted. As I said before, if the basic ideas supporting your idea are bad then you have to start ENTIRELY over. This isn't about being a work in progess. If you continued trying to morph this idea you'd still get nowhere with it. It's just plain bad.

 

 

 

Also, I'd like to point out that I literally spent over 70 hours working on my archaeology guide. Refining it, editing it, spellchecking, making sure things weren't overpowered and all were logical. I can tell you now you didn't even put a 10th of that work into this idea before you spat it out onto the forums.

 

 

 

Out of over 350 different responses from 350 different people, only about 5 or 6 did not approve of my idea, and most of them said they didn't because either A.) They didn't see the point in digging up rocks for exp (which means they did not read the entire guide as I requested) or B.) It is members only, and they were f2p, so they were being immature and not supporting because of it. (My argument being, if they are f2p, and it doesn't apply to them or they don't support because it doesn't apply to them, why respond to the topic at all?)

 

 

 

As you can see, I've yet to find any MAJOR flaws in my guide, and should one appear, it will be fixed. But the basis of my idea is so strong and appealing that people respond well to it.

 

 

 

I'm telling you now, if you want to throw your ideas on the forums you need to really study what makes Runescape what it is, and how you can fit a skill into the game that will not only fit the requirements of what a runescape skill demands, but also gives originality to the pre-existing ones. It's a hard balance, but I've proven with Archaeology it's possible.

 

 

 

I'm telling you now, flame me all you want, but it's not going to make your idea any better. If you want my advice, I'd say crumple this one up into a little ball, score a 3 pointer in your waste basket at the opposite end of your room, and call it a day.

[sees_all1]

Could we get a mod to just [/thread] ?

 

Seems to me that this idea hasn't taken on too well with TIF, probably because it looks like the idea is basically to add about 8 quests and package it as a "skill" - I did read through most of it, and I can't say I understand it.

 

Unless the author wants to clear things up, or put more work into it, let's just let it die.

 

[/fail]

[dv_trainer]

[/thread]

 

[/account]